19:07:13 , WELCOME TO THE OCTOBER 12th COUNCIL 19:07:16 MEETING. I'D LIKE TO CALL THE MEETING TO ORDER 19:07:20 AND WE'LL BEGIN WITH THE PLEDGE AND INCHES 19:07:23 COUNCILMEMBER JONES WOULD 19:07:26 YOU LIKE TO LEAD US IN THAT. 19:07:29 >> Councilmember Jones: AS LONG AS YOU DON'T ASK ME TO 19:07:33 STAND. I PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG 19:07:36 TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. AND TO THE REPUBLIC FOR WHICH IT 19:07:39 STANDS ONE NATION UNDER GOD 19:07:42 INDIVISIBLE WITH LIBERTY AND JUSTICE FOR ALL. 19:07:45 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE, NOT 19:07:48 ROLL 19:07:51 CALL PERIOD. >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER 19:07:55 COX, PRESENT. COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN, PRESENT. 19:07:59 COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN, HERE. COUNCILMEMBER JONES 19:08:03 . HERE. COUNCILMEMBER KENG. 19:08:06 HERE. VICE MAYOR SHAO 19:08:09 , PRESENT. MAYOR MEI 19:08:12 . >> Mayor Mei: HERE. AND AT THIS TIME, I'D LIKE TO 19:08:15 SEE IF THERE'S ANY ANNOUNCEMENTS BY 19:08:19 THE CITY MANAGER, BUT I'LL FIRST SAY THERE ARE VEINS 19:08:22 VACANCIES ON THE BOARDS 19:08:25 AND COMMISSIONS, 19:08:29 THE CITY COUNCIL ACCEPTANCE APPLICATION 19:08:32 S ALL TIME OF THE YEAR. PLEASE CONTACT 19:08:36 THE CITY CLERK'S'S OFFICE AT 510- 19:08:39 510-284-4060. 19:08:46 MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC PARTICIPATING IN THE ELECTRONIC MEETING WISHING TO SPEAK MAY 19:08:47 DO SO DURING PUBLIC COMMENT, BY CLICKING ON THE “RAISE HAND” ICON, OR IF CALLING IN BY 19:08:50 DIALING STAR 9. I WILL MAKE AN ANNOUNCEMENT BEFORE EACH SECTION OF THE 19:08:51 AGENDA. WE KINDLY REQUEST MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC TO MUTE OR TURN DOWN THE 19:08:52 BROADCAST, WHEN IT IS THEIR OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK, AS IT MAY CAUSE INTERFERENCE WITH THE 19:08:53 SPEAKER SYSTEM. EMAILS SUBMITTED TO THE CITY CLERK ARE COMPILED, DISTRIBUTED 19:08:56 TO THE CITY COUNCIL AND 19:09:01 STAFF, AND PUBLISHED IN THE CITY'S AGENDA CENTER ON 19:09:02 FREMONT.GOV, AND WILL BE PLACED ON FILE AND CONSIDERED PART OF THE PUBLIC RECORD. 19:09:05 I WOULD LIKE TO ANNOUNCE THIS MEETING WILL GO UNTIL 11:30 PM 19:09:09 THIS EVENING IF NEEDED. 19:09:12 WE WILL ALLOW FOR 30 MINUTES OF GENERAL PUBLIC COMMENT, UP TO THREE MINUTES PER SPEAKER. 19:09:14 IF THERE ARE ADDITIONAL SPEAKERS FOR ORAL COMMUNICATIONS, AFTER THE INITIAL 30 MINUTES, WE WILL 19:09:17 ALLOW THE ADDITIONAL SPEAKERS AT THE END OF THE MEETING 19:09:20 I WILL NOW TURN THE MEETING OVER TO ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER BRIAN 19:09:23 STOTT TO INTRODUCE STAFF AT THIS TIME. 19:09:26 >> GOOD EVENING, MAYOR, MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL. 19:09:29 I DON'T HAVE ANY ANNOUNCEMENTS THIS EVENING BUT 19:09:32 I AX JOINED AS ALWAYS WITH DEBRA 19:09:36 MARGOLIS, THE INTERIM CITY 19:09:39 ATTORNEY AND MEMBERS OF THE SENIOR STAFF. THANK YOU. 19:09:43 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. AND AT THIS TIME, WE'LL GO 19:09:46 TO THE CONSENT CALENDAR. AND CONSENT CALENDAR, ARE ITEMS 19:09:49 THAT WILL BE PASSED WITH ONE COUNCIL VOTE AND THE STAFF 19:09:52 RECOMMENDATION WILL STAND. ARE THERE ANY MEMBERS OF THE 19:09:56 PUBLIC WHO WISH TO PULL ANY ITEM FROM THE CONSENT CALENDAR 19:10:00 ? IF THEY WOULD LIKE TO DO SO 19:10:03 BYES FROMMING THE RAISE HAND ICON. I 19:10:07 SEE COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN HAS HIS HAND UP 19:10:10 . >> Councilmember Salwan: YES, ITEM 2C I'LL BE RECUSE 19:10:13 ING ON SINCE IT'S FREMONT BOULEVARD AND THAT'S WHERE 19:10:16 MY OFFICE IS LOCATED. AND THIS IS NOT A SPECIFIC 19:10:19 BENEFIT BUT JUST TO PREVENT ANY PERCEPTION OF BIAS 19:10:22 OR ANYTHING. 19:10:26 19:10:29 YOU KNOW. >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU 19:10:32 . MAY I GET A MOTION TO MOVE THE CONSENT CALENDAR 19:10:35 . >> Councilmember Jones: SO MOVED. 19:10:38 >> Mayor Mei: MOVED BY COUNCILMEMBER JONES AND SECONDED 19:10:41 BY COUNCILMEMBER COX. ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE. 19:10:44 >> The Clerk: CAN COUNCILMEMBER COX. >> Councilmember Cox: AYE. 19:10:45 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN. 19:10:48 >> Councilmember Salwan: AYE. >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN 19:10:52 . >> Councilmember Kassan: AYE. >> The Clerk: 19:10:56 COUNCILMEMBER JONES. >> Councilmember Jones: AYE. 19:10:59 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER KENG. 19:11:02 >> Councilmember Keng: AYE. 19:11:06 >> The Clerk: VICE MAYOR SHAO. >> Councilmember Shao: 19:11:09 AYE. >> The Clerk: MAYOR 19:11:12 MEI PAP. >> Mayor Mei: THE 19:11:15 CAN CONSENT CALENDAR PASS IS WITH 19:11:19 CLS RECUSE YOU CAN HIMSELF ON ONE ITEM. 19:11:23 ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH MONTH. I'LL READ THE FOLLOWING 19:11:26 . CHILDREN'S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH MONTH. 19:11:30 OCTOBER 2021. 19:11:33 WHEREAS, THE AIM OF CHILDREN’S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH CEH MONTH 19:11:36 IS TO RAISE AWARENESS ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF CLEAN AIR AND 19:11:38 WATER, SAFE FOOD AND CONSUMER PRODUCTS, HEALTHY ENVIRONMENTS, AND STABLE CLIMATES TO 19:11:41 CHILDREN’S HEALTH AND 19:11:45 DEVELOPMENT; AND WHEREAS, A STATEWIDE CEH MONTH WAS 19:11:48 ESTABLISHED ON SEPTEMBER 1, 2021 THROUGH HOUSE RESOLUTION 68, BY 19:11:56 THE CALIFORNIA STATE ASSEMBLY; AND WHEREAS, CEH MONTH PROVIDES 19:11:59 A MEANS TO CELEBRATE THE PROGRESS OF THE CHILDREN’S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH MOVEMENT 19:12:02 AND CREATE AN EVEN STRONGER NETWORK OF CHILD HEALTH ADVOCATES; AND WHEREAS, 19:12:06 ENVIRONMENTAL RISKS HAVE AN IMPACT ON THE HEALTH AND 19:12:09 DEVELOPMENT OF CHILDREN, FROM CONCEPTION THROUGH CHILDHOOD AND ADOLESCENCE AND ALSO INTO 19:12:12 ADULTHOOD. 19:12:15 CHILDREN BREATHE MORE AIR, CONSUME MORE FOOD, AND DRINK 19:12:18 MORE WATER THAN ADULTS DO, IN PROPORTION TO THEIR WEIGHT; 19:12:21 CHILDREN'S SYSTEMS ARE STILL DEVELOPING; AND WHEREAS, THESE 19:12:24 ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ISSUES TO CHILDREN INCLUDE CHEMICAL POLLUTION, AIR POLLUTION, 19:12:28 CLIMATE CHANGE, DISEASE-CAUSING MICROBES, LACK OF ACCESS TO 19:12:32 HEALTH CARE, POOR INFRASTRUCTURE, AND POOR WATER 19:12:35 QUALITY; AND WHEREAS, CEH MONTH 19:12:39 ENCOURAGES INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS TO RAISE AWARENESS 19:12:42 AND UNDERSTANDING OF CHILDREN’S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH ISSUES, 19:12:45 SEEK IMPROVED PROTECTIONS FOR ALL CHILDREN, AND TO PERFORM 19:12:49 ACTS OF SUSTAINABILITY OR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH 19:12:52 WELLNESS; AND WHEREAS, TOGETHER, WE CAN SAFEGUARD THE HEALTH, 19:12:55 SAFETY AND WELLBEING OF OUR MOST 19:12:59 PRECIOUS RESOURCE: CHILDREN. 19:13:02 NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FREMONT, PROCLAIM 19:13:06 THE MONTH OF OCTOBER AS CHILDREN’S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH 19:13:09 MONTH AND URGE ALL CITIZENS TO OBSERVE THIS MONTH WITH 19:13:14 AWARENESS-RAISING AND ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH AND 19:13:16 STEWARDSHIP ACTIVITIES TO CREATE A HEALTHIER ENVIRONMENT FOR OUR 19:13:23 CHILDREN. AND SO I THINK WE HAVE KATIE 19:13:26 BOLIN WHO WILL ACCEPT AND SAY A FEW WORDS. 19:13:30 AND I ALSO SEE 19:13:33 RACIALLY de FRANK 19:13:37 FRANCO TO 19:13:40 SAY A FEW WORDS. >> FIRST AND FOREMOST 19:13:43 , MAYOR MEI, CITY COUNCIL AND STAFF FOR ALLOWING ME 19:13:47 TO SPEAK THIS MONTH AND PROCLAIMING 19:13:50 OCTOBER AS CHILDREN'S ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH MONTH 19:13:53 . I AM ONE AFFECTED BY THE 19:13:56 SOUTHWEST AIRLINES 19:14:00 CANCELLATIONS. BECAUSE I'M NURSE AND WORK IN 19:14:04 PUBLIC HEALTH I'LL KEEP MY MASK ON AS I SPEAK. 19:14:07 BUT PLEASE LET ME KNOW IF YOU CANNOT HEAR ME. 19:14:10 UP MY NAME IS KATIE BOLIN, I'M 19:14:13 A REGISTERED NURSE, MASTERS OF 19:14:16 PUBLIC HEALTH STUDENT, 19:14:20 AND A MEMBER HE CALIFORNIA 19:14:24 ANE, WE WOULD LIKE TO THANK 19:14:27 FREMONT CITY COUNCIL TO 19:14:31 FTC 19:14:34 BY 19:14:38 PROCLAIMING OCTOBER AS CHILDREN'S 19:14:41 ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH MONTH. WE THANK YOU FOR STANDING UP FOR 19:14:44 CALIFORNIA KIDS. AS A NURSE I KNOW WELL THAT THE 19:14:47 AIR WATER FOOD AND CHEMICALS IN 19:14:51 OUR EVERYDAY PRODUCTS, AS WELL AS CLIMATE CHANGE CAN 19:14:54 GREATLY AFFECT THE HEALTH OF CHILDREN IN THIS STATE. 19:14:56 HOWEVER, I BELIEVE THAT NO PARENTS SHOULD HAVE TO WORRY 19:15:00 ABOUT THEIR ENVIRONMENT BRINGING HARM TO THEIR CHILD'S HEALTH AND 19:15:03 NO PARENT SHOULD HAVE TO WORRY MORE ABOUT THEIR CHILD'S HEALTH 19:15:07 THAN THEIR MORE PRIVILEGED COUNTERPARTS. 19:15:09 THAT IS WHY THE TIME TO ACT IS NOW. 19:15:12 CHILDREN ARE OUR FUTURE AND THEY DESERVE TO HAVE A FUTURE THAT IS HEALTHY 19:15:15 , EQUITABLE AND SUSTAINABILITY. THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME AND 19:15:23 COMMITMENT TO THIS CAUSE. >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU FOR BRINGING THIS TO OUR ATTENTION 19:15:26 AND I ALSO WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE COUNCILMEMBER COX AND 19:15:31 ALSO RACIALLY de FRANCO. I KNOW WE HAVE 19:15:34 TALKED ABOUT THIS AND I THINK WE'RE SUBMITTING SOME APPLICATIONS FOR 19:15:38 , THERE IS A CONTEST WITHIN NATIONAL LEAGUE OF CITIES AND OTHERS 19:15:41 THAT HOPEFULLY WE WILL BE SUBMITTING BECAUSE WE HAVE 19:15:44 SO MANY EXCELLENT PROJECTS WITHIN OUR CITY FROM 19:15:47 OUR YOUTH LEADERSHIP AS WELL AS OUR STAFF THAT WILL BE PERHAPS 19:15:50 WELL RECOGNIZED AND HIGHLIGHTED. SO THANK YOU FOR ALL THAT YOU 19:15:53 DO, KATIE AND HIGHLIGHTING THIS ISSUE, 19:15:57 IT IS DEFINITELY A GROWING NEED IN TERMS OF 19:15:59 AWARENESS. ESPECIALLY NOW WITH SOME OF THE 19:16:03 E-WASTE RECYCLING AND OTHER THINGS THAT CAN IMPACT 19:16:06 THE SOIL AND WATER RESOURCES. SO IT IS REALLY 19:16:09 CRITICAL FOR US TO BE ABLE TO HIGHLIGHT THIS. SO I JUST WANT 19:16:13 ED TO SAY THANK YOU. NEXT IS A PROCLAMATION 19:16:14 FOR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AWARENESS MONTH. 19:16:18 AND I WANTED TO SHARE THAT, TOO. I THINK 19:16:21 THAT THEY MAY STILL BE OUTSIDE. THEY ARE ACTUALLY OUTSIDE OF 19:16:24 MY DOOR JUST A FEW MINUTES AGO, EARLIER. 19:16:27 AND I SEE -- ACTUALLY I SEE JENNIFER YOU ARE STILL THERE 19:16:30 . I SEE YOU OUTSIDE. AND SO I WANTED TO WAVE TO 19:16:33 YOU. AND WE SHARED THIS EARLIER 19:16:36 THIS EVENING. AND I WANTED TO THANK JENNIFER 19:16:39 AND ALL THOSE WHO CAME THIS EVENING TO HIGHLIGHT THE NEED FOR 19:16:42 THIS AWARENESS FOR PROCLAMATION ON 19:16:45 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AWARENESS MONTH. AND THIS IS BEING 19:16:49 OCTOBER 2021. 19:16:52 WHEREAS, ONE IN FOUR WOMEN, ONE IN EIGHT MEN, AND NEARLY HALF OF TRANSGENDER INDIVIDUALS IN THE 19:16:55 UNITED STATES IS A VICTIM OF 19:16:57 EMOTIONAL, VERBAL, FINANCIAL, SEXUAL, PHYSICAL OR OTHER FORMS 19:17:00 OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE PERPETRATED BY A CURRENT OR FORMER INTIMATE 19:17:04 PARTNER; AND WHEREAS, DOMESTIC VIOLENCE KNOWS NO BOUNDARIES AND 19:17:07 CAN IMPACT ANYONE REGARDLESS OF AGE, ECONOMIC STATUS, FAITH, 19:17:11 RACE, ETHNICITY, GENDER IDENTITY, SEXUAL ORIENTATION, 19:17:14 LEVEL OF EDUCATION, ABILITY, LANGUAGE SPOKEN, OR GEOGRAPHIC 19:17:20 LOCATION; AND WHEREAS, DOMESTIC 19:17:23 VIOLENCE IS A SERIOUS THREAT TO THE WELL-BEING OF THE PARTIES 19:17:26 INVOLVED AND TO OUR COMMUNITY, SIGNIFICANTLY IMPACTS MENTAL 19:17:30 HEALTH AND MEDICAL RESOURCES, PERSONAL AND PUBLIC SAFETY, AND 19:17:33 WORK PRODUCTIVITY; AND WHEREAS, PROVIDING COMPASSIONATE AND 19:17:36 INCLUSIVE SUPPORT THROUGH PROGRAMS AND SERVICES SUCH AS: 19:17:39 EMERGENCY SAFE HOUSES AND OTHER HOUSING SUPPORTS; 24-HOUR CRISIS 19:17:44 HOTLINES; ADULT, CHILD, FAMILY, AND GROUP COUNSELING; AND POLICE 19:17:49 DEPARTMENT AND COURT-BASED VICTIM ADVOCACY SERVICES; AND WHEREAS, DURING DOMESTIC 19:17:52 VIOLENCE AWARENESS MONTH, WE 19:17:55 RECOGNIZE THE TREMENDOUS PROGRESS MADE BY SAVE IN 19:17:59 REDUCING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE, AND WE RECOMMIT THAT EVERYONE HAS 19:18:01 THE RIGHT TO A SAFE AND HEALTHY RELATIONSHIP AND TO LIVE FREE OF 19:18:07 ABUSE. NOW, THEREFORE, THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF FREMONT, PROCLAIM 19:18:10 OCTOBER 2021 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AWARENESS AND PREVENTION MONTH 19:18:13 AND URGES ALL CITIZENS TO WORK TOWARD ENDING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE 19:18:16 BY EMPOWERING AND ASSISTING INDIVIDUALS AND FAMILIES TO 19:18:20 ACCESS THE INFORMATION AND SUPPORTIVE SERVICES THEY NEED, 19:18:25 INSTITUTING EFFECTIVE AWARENESS, INTERVENTION, AND PREVENTION 19:18:28 POLICIES WITHIN OUR COMMUNITY, AND ENGAGING ONE ANOTHER IN SAFE 19:18:30 DISCUSSIONS ABOUT DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SO THAT DOMESTIC 19:18:33 VIOLENCE, A CRIME THAT THRIVES ON SECRECY, IS ENDED. 19:18:43 AND I APOLOGIZE, I FORGOT TO GIVE THIS WITH YOU, I ACTUALLY 19:18:46 HAD IT WITH ME WHEN I WAS OUTSIDE WITH YOU 19:18:50 . I'LL BE HAPPY TO HAND IT TO YOU IF YOU COME BY MY DOOR 19:18:53 . I WANTED TO LET YOU KNOW THAT I REALLY APPRECIATE THE FACT 19:18:56 THAT WE HAVE SEVERAL MEMBERS OF OUR COMMUNITY WHO ARE GATHER 19:18:59 ED OUTSIDE FOR A CANDLELIGHT VIGIL AND 19:19:03 IN FACT EARLIER WE HEARD FROM ONE OF THE INDIVIDUALS ANN 19:19:06 ANNIE WHO SHARED A BEAUTIFUL POEM 19:19:09 WHO EXPRESSED HOW IT 19:19:13 WAS A NEED TO BE AWARE OF THIS ISSUE 19:19:16 JUST NOT ONLY FOUR YOURSELF BUT 19:19:19 FOR MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY AND PROVIDE THAT RESOURCE AND 19:19:23 ABILITY TO SUPPORT THAT WITHIN OUR SOCIETY. I THANK YOU TOO, WE 19:19:27 HAVE REPRESENTATIVES FROM SUPERVISOR 19:19:30 HALBERT'S 19:19:33 T'S OFFERS AND 19:19:36 STATE SENATOR WIECKOWSKI'S OFFICE 19:19:40 . JENNIFER. >> THANK YOU MAYOR MEI, AND 19:19:43 THANK YOU COUNCILMEMBER KENG FOR JOINING US. 19:19:46 WE JUST WRAPPED UP OUR CANDLELIGHT 19:19:49 VIGIL, WE ARE STILL HERE, I'M HERE WITH OUR 19:19:52 DIRECTOR OF PROGRAMS, KATE, AND WE'RE 19:19:56 REALLY GRATEFUL FOR THE RECOGNITION AND FOR EVERYONE 19:19:59 'S SUPPORT, SAFE HAS BEEN 19:20:02 HERE FOR 40 YEARS SERVING THE COMMUNITY AND 19:20:05 , YOU KNOW, I KNOW THAT DURING THE COURSE OF THIS PANDEMIC EVERYONE 19:20:08 'S BEEN SAYING NOW MORE THAN EVER, YOUR 19:20:11 SUPPORT IS NEEDED. AND YOU KNOW IT'S CERTAINLY TRUE 19:20:14 IN THE CASE OF INTIMATE PARTNER VIOLENCE. 19:20:17 SO I JUST KEEP IT SHORT AND SWEET. THANK YOU, 19:20:20 THANK YOU, THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT. 19:20:24 AND HOPE TO SEE EVERYONE AT OUR VIGIL 19:20:27 NEXT YEAR. >> Mayor Mei: YES, WE HOPE TO BE WITH 19:20:30 YOU IN PERSON RATHER THAN JUST IN SPIRIT. AND THAT'S JUST TO 19:20:34 LET PEOPLE KNOW I KNOW BOTH COUNCILMEMBER KENG AND I ARE 19:20:37 WEARING PURPLE RIBBONS JUST 19:20:40 TO REPRESENT, I THINK SOME OF THE STAFF MEMBERS AND 19:20:44 COUNCILMEMBERS ARE ALSO WEARING PURPLE TO SHOW THEIR SUPPORT. 19:20:47 I WANTED TO EXPRESS THAT HOW IMPORTANT IT IS FOR 19:20:50 US TO BE AWARE OF THIS. THANK YOU SO MUCH AND IF I SEE 19:20:53 YOU PASSING BY I'LL PROBABLY RUN OUT AND GIVE 19:20:56 YOU THE PROCLAMATION. OTHERWISE WE'LL HAVE TO MEET UP 19:20:59 ANOTHER TIME. NEXT IS A PRESENTATION WHICH IS VERY IMPORTANT TO US AS A 19:21:02 CITY. WE ALSO WERE -- IT'S 19:21:05 A PRESENTATION OF THE PLATINUM LEVEL BEACON 19:21:09 VANGUARD WATER FOR OUR CITY 19:21:12 'S LEADERSHIP AND INNOVATION AWARD FOR 19:21:15 THE INSTITUTION OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT. I KNOW WE HAVE 19:21:18 KARALEE BROWNE AND NIKITA 19:21:22 SINHA FROM ILG WHO ARE 19:21:26 GOING TO SHARE A PRESENTATION. IN PARTICULAR I WANT TO 19:21:29 RECOGNIZE AND ACKNOWLEDGE 19:21:33 DAN SCHOENHOLZ, AS WELL AS OUR 19:21:36 SUSTAINABILITY DIRECTOR RACHEL 19:21:43 WHO WILL BE 19:21:46 ACCEPTING. OUR CLIMATE PROCESS 19:21:49 WILL BE THE NEXT 19:21:53 IN OUR GOALS FOR ONET 19:21:56 CARBON NEUTRALITY BY THE YEAR 2025. 19:21:59 YOU CAN LEARN MORE ABOUT THIS AS WE TALK ABOUT THIS IN THE 19:22:02 SUSTAINABILITY SECTION OF OUR CITY'S WEBSITE AND YOU CAN 69 19:22:05 U 19:22:09 SIGN UP FOR 19:22:12 OUR GOALS. I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR FROM IL 19:22:15 G. >> THANK YOU, MAYOR MEI. I'M JUST GOING 19:22:18 DO SHARE MY SCREEN. SO 19:22:21 GOOD EVENING, EVERYBODY. MY NAME IS NIKITA 19:22:25 SINHA, I'M A PROGRAM MANAGER FOR THE INSTITUTE 19:22:28 FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT. IN CASE YOU'RE NOT FAMILIAR 19:22:31 WITH ILG WE ARE THE TRAINING AFFILIATE OF THE LEAGUE 19:22:34 OF CALIFORNIA CITIES ALONG WITH THE 19:22:36 CALIFORNIA STATE ASSOCIATION OF COUNTIES AND THE CALIFORNIA 19:22:40 DISTRICT ASSOCIATION. IN 2010 ILG LAUNCHED 19:22:43 THE BEACON PROGRAM AS A RECOGNITION PROGRAM ACKNOWLEDGING THE 19:22:47 MANY STEPS LOCAL GOVERNMENT WERE PROACTIVELY TAKING 19:22:50 TO ADDRESS ENERGY EFFICIENCY AND CLIMATE CHANGE. 19:22:53 OVER THE PAST DECADE THIS PROGRAM HAS EVOLVED INTO A FRAMEWORK 19:22:56 WHERE CITIES AND COUNTIES CAN PLAN SHARE AND 19:23:00 INNOVATE STRATEGIES AND PROGRAMS TO ADDRESS A VARIETY OF CLIMATE 19:23:03 RELATED ISSUES FACING 19:23:07 OUR CITIES AND OUR STATE. 19:23:10 THE BEACON PROGRAM HONORS PARTICIPANTS FOR 19:23:13 ACHIEVEMENTS IF FIVE SPOTLIGHT CATEGORIES 19:23:16 , ENERGY SAVINGS, NATIONAL 19:23:20 GAS SAVINGS, AGENCY GREENHOUSE GAS UKS 19:23:23 REDUCTIONS, SUSTAINABILITY PRACTICES. 19:23:28 AFTER SEVERING AN WATER IN ALL FIVE CATEGORIES, THE 19:23:31 CITY CAN QUALIFIES FOR THE HIGHEST AWARD 19:23:34 , THE BEACON VANGUARD AWARD 19:23:37 . THIS YEAR WE ARE HAPPY TO AWARD 19:23:41 THE CITY OF FREMONT THE HIGHEST LEVEL AWARD, 19:23:44 THE BEACON VAN 19:23:47 PLATINUM VANGUARD AWARD. 19:23:50 25%, 46 19:23:54 % SAVINGS IN ENERGY AND 33 19:23:57 % SAVINGS IN NATURAL GAS IN 19:24:00 AGENCY SAVINGS, FREMONT IS JUST ONE OF 19:24:04 FIVE AGENCIES STATEWIDE THAT HAS RECEIVED 19:24:07 THE BEACON AWARD AT THE 19:24:10 PLATINUM LEVEL. THIS YEAR WE AWARDED FREMONT 19:24:13 THE INAUGURAL BY THE WAY CONAWARD 19:24:18 , FREMONT HAS MADE GREAT STRIDES 19:24:21 IN ELECTRIFYING ITS GRID. FREMONT IS 19:24:24 AN EXEMPLARY PARTICIPANT OF THE PROGRAM AND WE 19:24:28 ARE PROUD TO RECOGNIZE THEM AS A 19:24:31 LEADER IN SUSTAINABILITY ACROSS THE STATE. WE 19:24:35 ARE HAPPY TO CONGRATULATE FREMONT AND THE SUSTAIN 19:24:38 ABILITY DIVISION. 19:24:41 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH I'D LOVE TO TURN 19:24:45 THIS OVER TO DAN AND RACIALLY IF THEY WOULD LIKE 19:24:48 TO SAY ANYTHING AND THANK YOU TO THE COMMUNITY AND STAFF 19:24:52 WHO HAVE MADE THIS POSSIBLE. 19:24:55 >> Dan Schoenholz: THANK YOU, MAYOR MEI AND NIKITA 19:24:58 . THE INSTITUTION FOR LOCAL GOVERNMENT FOR RECOGNIZE 19:25:01 ING THE CITY FOR OUR TREMENDOUS STRIDES IN 19:25:04 REDUCE YOU GRATION EMISSION 19:25:11 ING GRATION 19:25:19 REDUCING GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS. 19:25:23 SERVES MOST FREMONT RESIDENTS AND BUSINESSES. ANOTHER BIG 19:25:26 FACTOR HAS BEEN THAT THE COMMUNITY HAS REALLY EMBRACE 19:25:29 EMBRACED SOLAR AND ALSO ELECTRIC VEHICLES, IN A BIG 19:25:32 WAY. WITH ONE OF OUR ZIP CODES HAVING THE 19:25:35 HIGHEST PERCENTAGE OF ELECTRIC VEHICLES OF ANY 19:25:38 ZIP CODE IN THE ENTIRE STATE. IN TERMS 19:25:42 OF CITY OPERATIONS, SUSTAINABILITY HAS BEEN AN 19:25:45 ORGANIZATION-WIDE EFFORT. A FEW 19:25:48 EXAMPLES, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT MANAGED A CITYWIDE ENERGY 19:25:52 AND WATER EFFICIENCY UPGRADE THAT INCLUDED REPLACING 19:25:55 ALL CITY STREET LIGHTS WITH ENERGY-SAVING 19:25:59 LED'S. THE POLICE DEPARTMENT HAS GAINED NATIONAL 19:26:02 ATTENTION FOR ITS PIONEERING USE OF AN ALL 19:26:05 ELECTRIC PATROL VEHICLE. THE FIRE DEPARTMENT IS A LEADER 19:26:09 IN ADOPTING SOLAR BATTERY MICROGRID 19:26:12 SYSTEMS THAT ALSO ALLOW FOR RESILIENCY 19:26:16 IN THE EVENT OF POWER OUTAGES. PUBLIC WORKS HAS SPEARHEAD 19:26:20 ED PROJECTS AND PROGRAMS SUPPORTING BICYCLISTS 19:26:23 AND PEDESTRIANS AND COMMUNITY SERVICES OVERSEES THE 19:26:25 CITY'S EXTREMELY SUCCESSFUL RECYCLING PROGRAMS. 19:26:29 AND I COULD GIVE LOTS MORE EXAMPLES BUT I WILL STOP THERE 19:26:32 . I'D LIKE TO ACKNOWLEDGE THE MEMBERS 19:26:35 OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY COMMISSION WHO HAVE PROVIDED 19:26:39 VALUABLE INPUT TO STAFF ON NUMEROUS ISSUES. AND 19:26:42 OF COURSE, THE CITY COUNCIL FOR YOUR STEADFAST SUPPORT OF 19:26:45 OUR CLIMATE ACTION IMPLEMENTATION EFFORTS. 19:26:48 AND FINALLY, I'D LIKE TO RECOGNIZE A COUPLE OF PEOPLE ON 19:26:51 MY STAFF. FIRST, THE CITY'S 19:26:54 SUSTAINABILITY MANAGER, RACIALLY de 19:26:57 FRANCO WHOSE EXPERTISE, PROJECT MANAGEMENT 19:27:00 SKILLS AND PASSION FOR THE WORK HAVE ELEVATED FREMONT'S 19:27:04 PROFILE AS A LEADER IN MUNICIPAL SUSTAINABILITY. 19:27:07 AND I'D ALSO LIKE TO ACKNOWLEDGE 19:27:11 MANAGEMENT ANALYST IN MY DEPARTMENT, LUCIAN 19:27:14 A TORREZ WHO HAS BEEN INSTRUMENTAL IN SUPPORTING 19:27:17 OUR EFFORTS BEHIND THE SCENES. THANKS AGAIN 19:27:20 TO THE I ALL RIGHTG FOR THIS HONOR AND I'LL TURN THINGS 19:27:24 BACK OVER TO MAYOR MEI. >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU 19:27:27 DAN TO YOU AND THE ENTIRE TEAM AND ALSO I SEE 19:27:30 CHIEF JACOBSEN AND CHIEF WASHINGTON ON 19:27:33 THE CALL. IT'S BEEN TRULY A COMMUNITY EFFORT 19:27:36 , ONE THAT'S FROM THE CITY TEAM 19:27:40 AND IN PARTNERSHIP WITHI HADG AND SO MANY OF 19:27:43 OUR BUSINESSES WITHIN THE CITY OF FREMONT AND WORKING ON THE 19:27:46 OPPORTUNITY TO PURSUE THESE GRAND AND 19:27:49 THEN ALSO WITH LEADERSHIP IN WORKING WITH ORGANIZATIONS LIKE E 19:27:52 BCE AND OTHERS THAT HELP US ACHIEVE THIS GOAL 19:27:56 . AND SO WE'RE JUST TRULY PROUD TO BE ONE OF THE 19:27:59 FIVE CITIES, AND I THINK IT'S THE BIGGEST CITY THAT IS 19:28:02 RECOGNIZED FOR THE PLATINUM AWARD. AND HOPEFULLY WE 19:28:05 CAN CELEBRATE IN PERSON NEXT TIME. 19:28:08 SO THANK YOU FOR THIS RECOGNITION, WE'RE VERY PROUD TO 19:28:11 BE ABLE TO HAVE THIS AS ANOTHER FEATHER IN THE CAP 19:28:14 BUT MORE IMPORTANTLY, TO BE ABLE TO CHANGE THIS NOT JUST FOR 19:28:18 OURSELVES BUT FOR FUTURE GENERATIONS AND SO THANK YOU. 19:28:19 THANK YOU FOR COMING THIS EVENING. 19:28:22 AND FOR SHARING WITH US NIKITA 19:28:26 AND WE LOOK FORWARD TO BEING ABLE 19:28:29 TO WORK WITH YOU AND THE ILG TEAM 19:28:32 AS WE MOVE FORWARD WITH THE LEAGUE OF CALIFORNIA CITIES. 19:28:35 NEXT ON OUR AGENDA ITEM THIS EVENING 19:28:39 IS PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONS. AND THOSE ARE 19:28:42 ITEMS THAT ARE 19:28:47 NOT AGENDIZED THIS EVENING. AND SO I 19:28:50 WAS WONDERING IF THERE ARE ANY HANDS FOR THAT 19:28:53 . 19:28:57 OKAY. I'M GOING TO CLOSE 19:29:00 ORAL COMMUNICATIONS. AND I WILL RETURN IT BACK 19:29:05 TO ITEM 7A. I'M GOING TO ASK 19:29:08 FOR YOUR INDULGENCE IN THIS. 19:29:12 WE HAVE THIS EVENING LEGISLATIVE UPDATE, 19:29:15 A BRIEF LEGISLATIVE UPDATE FROM SENATOR BOB WIECKOWSKI WHO I 19:29:18 JUST SAW EARLIER THIS EVENING. AND HE'S GOING TO GIVE US A 19:29:22 PRESENTATION ON SOME OF THE GREAT THINGS THAT HAVE BEEN HAPPENING 19:29:25 IN SENATE DISTRICT 10. AND THIS 19:29:28 WILL BE HEARD BEFORE ITEM 5A. WHICH IS 19:29:31 OUR AFFORDABLE HOUSING UPDATE THIS EVENING. AND SO I'D LIKE TO 19:29:35 WELCOME SENATOR 19:29:40 WIECKOWSKI TO OUR COUNCIL MEETING TONIGHT – ALTHOUGH 19:29:43 WE’RE VIRTUAL, I’M SURE BEING A PART OF OUR MEETING TONIGHT 19:29:47 FEELS A LITTLE FAMILIAR BECAUSE YOU WERE FORMERLY A 19:29:50 COUNCILMEMBER HERE. 19:29:53 THE CITY OF FREMONT IS GRATEFUL TO HAVE DEEPLY COMMITTED REPRESENTATIVES IN THE STATE 19:29:54 LEGISLATURE WHO HAVE BEEN INSTRUMENTAL IN ADVOCATING ON BEHALF OF THE CITY'S NEEDS 19:29:57 AND PRIORITIES. 19:30:00 THIS YEAR, CITY STAFF HAS HAD THE OPPORTUNITY TO WORK CLOSELY 19:30:03 WITH THE SENATOR'S OFFICE AND I'VE HAD 19:30:06 SOME CONVERSATIONS WITH HIM, TOO, ON SUPPORTING THE BUDGET 19:30:09 REQUESTS, THE LEGISLATION AND KEY PROJECTS FOR 19:30:12 US IN THE CITY. 19:30:16 ONE OF THE MOST SIGNIFICANT OUTCOMES OF THIS PAST YEAR, WAS OUR ABILITY TO SECURE 19:30:19 $7.2M IN A STATE BUDGET REQUEST, FOR THE I-680/MISSION BOULEVARD INTERCHANGE MODERNIZATION 19:30:25 PROJECT TO ASSIST THIS PROJECT TO BECOME SHOVEL READY. 19:30:28 THIS WAS A MONUMENTAL WIN FOR THE CITY'S TRANSPORTATION PRIORITIES, AND WE'D LIKE TO 19:30:31 THANK YOU, SENATOR WIECKOWSKI FOR YOUR EFFORTS AS WELL AS THE 19:30:35 SUPPORT OF ASSEMBLYMEMBER QUIRK. YOU AND YOUR STAFF HAVE BEEN A 19:30:43 EXCELLENT PARTNER OVER THE YEARS, WE APPRECIATE WHAT THAT 19:30:46 YOU WANTED TO BE HERE TONIGHT 19:30:49 AND TALK ABOUT 19:30:52 LEGISLATION YOU HAVE CHAMPIONED THIS PAST YEAR AND WE ALSO LOOK 19:30:55 FORWARD TO HEARING WHAT YOUR INITIAL PLANS ARE FOR THE 2022 SESSION. 19:30:59 AS WE WOULD BE GLAD TO PARTNER WITH YOU ON THAT SUCCESS. 19:31:02 >> GOOD EVENING, MAYOR MEI, REALLY 19:31:05 LOOK FORWARD TO ACTUALLY MEETING IN PERSON INSTEAD OF OUR ZOOM 19:31:08 S. THANK YOU FOR GIVING ME THIS OPPORTUNITY TO PROVIDE 19:31:12 A BRIEF UPDATE OF THE STATE LEGISLATURE'S ACTIONS 19:31:16 , AND MY LEGISLATIVE AGENDA IN THE FIRST HALF OF THIS 19:31:19 TWO-YEAR SESSION. I KNOW THAT WE HAVE LIMITED TIME. 19:31:22 SO I'LL GET RIGHT TO IT. MUCH OF THE LEGISLATURE'S WORK 19:31:25 THIS YEAR WAS OBVIOUSLY FOCUSED 19:31:28 ON HELPING CALIFORNIA BOUNCE BACK IN RESPONSE TO THE 19:31:32 COVID-19 PANDEMIC. BUT WE ALSO REBUILT OUR ECONOMY 19:31:35 AND WE WORK TO MAKE IT MORE EQUITABLE 19:31:39 THAN -- THAN A JUST RECOVERY HAD 19:31:43 PREVIOUSLY BEEN IN THE PAST. WE'VE ALSO WORKED TO MAKE AN 19:31:46 UNPRECEDENTED INVESTMENT OF $15 BILLION IN 19:31:49 OUR CLIMATE CHANGE PACKAGE, IN PROGRAMS 19:31:52 THAT PREVENT AND MITIGATE WHAT 19:31:55 WILDFIRES CONFRONT OUR DROUGHT AND TRANSITION CALIFORNIA TO 19:31:59 A ZERO-EMISSION VEHICLES SOCIETY 19:32:02 AS WE CURB OUR GREENHOUSE GASES 19:32:05 AND AS LOVELY AS THE PRESENTATION ON HOW FREMONT'S 19:32:08 LEADING THE WAY. NOW SINCE THE BEGINNING OF THE COVID-19 19:32:11 PANDEMIC, CALIFORNIA MOVED AGGRESSIVELY TO PROTECT 19:32:14 PUBLIC HEALTH. WE DID IT WITH THE SUPPORT AND 19:32:17 COLLABORATION OF OUR PARTNERS. THAT INCLUDES ALL OUR LOCAL CITIES, 19:32:20 OUR HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONALS AND COMMUNITY COMPLINGS. 19:32:24 CLINICS. WE'VE HAD GOOD 19:32:27 RESULTS HERE IN 19:32:30 ALAMEDA COUNTY COMPARED TO OTHER AREAS. 19:32:33 75% OF ALL CALIFORNIANS ARE VACCINATED 19:32:37 AND ANOTHER 8% ARE PARTIALLY VACCINATED. 19:32:40 WE HAVE ONE OF THE LOWEST POSITIVE 19:32:43 ITY RATES IN THE UNITED STATES DESPITE 19:32:46 OUR LARGE POPULATION. AND ARE 19:32:49 LIKE NEW YORK, NEW JERSEY, 19:32:53 TEXAS AND FLORIDA BUT WE KNOW WE HAVE 19:32:56 TO REMAIN VIGILANT AGAINST THE DELTA VARIANT 19:32:59 AND OTHER VARIANTS AND CONTINUE TO PUSH A 19:33:02 ROBUST VACCINATION EFFORT. YOU KNOW, SAD 19:33:06 LY WE'VE LOST 70,000 CLARCHES TO COVID 19:33:09 AND IT'S STILL TAKING A TOLL IN AREAS OF 19:33:12 OUR STATES PARTICULARLY AMONGST THOSE THAT ARE UNVACCINATED 19:33:15 . THE LEGISLATURE'S FOCUS THIS YEAR HAS NOT ONLY BEEN ON THE 19:33:18 VACCINATION ROLLOUT BUT ON OUR ECONOMIC RECOVERY 19:33:21 FROM COVID. AND ESPECIALLY FOR THOSE IN OUR 19:33:24 OUR -- THE LOW-INCOME BRACKET. CALIFORNIA 19:33:28 LEGISLATURE BACK IN FEBRUARY, I KNOW IT SEEMS LIKE A LONG TIME AGO 19:33:31 , APPROVED AND GOVERNOR NEWSOM 19:33:35 SIGNED AN IMMEDIATE RELIEF AND STIMULUS PACKAGE FOR FAMILIES AROUND 19:33:37 BUSINESSES HIT HARDEST BY THE PANDEMIC. 19:33:40 THIS WAS CALIFORNIA'S FEBRUARY STIMULUS PACKAGE 19:33:44 WHICH CONSISTED OF $7.6 19:33:47 BILLION OF ASSISTANCE IN THE FORM OF FEE RELIEF, ROUND 19:33:50 ONE OF THE GOLDEN STATE STIMULUS IS PAYMENTS, CHILDCARE 19:33:54 SUBSIDIES, STUDENT AID AND AID TO SMALL BUSINESSES 19:33:57 . NOW FAMILIES AND BUSINESSES THAT HAD 19:34:00 PREVIOUSLY QUALIFIED FOR STATE PROGRAMS AND FEDERAL RELIEF, THOSE 19:34:03 ARE THE CAL EITC 19:34:06 , CAL WORKS, CAL FRESH, THE 19:34:09 STATE'S SMALL BUSINESS GRANTS AND THE FEDERAL PP 19:34:12 P BUSINESS LOANS ALL BENEFITED 19:34:16 FROM THIS CALIFORNIA STIMULUS AND RELIEF PACKAGE 19:34:19 . WE'VE BUILT UP STABLE BUDGET RESERVES OVER THE 19:34:22 YEARS WITHIN OUR PROGRESSIVE TAX SYSTEM AND THIS YEAR WE'VE SEEN 19:34:25 INCREASES IN REVENUE, BOLSTERED IN PART BY 19:34:29 THE FEDERAL PANDEMIC RELIEF WHICH ALLOWED US TO 19:34:32 PASS ON THE STATE'S BIGGEST 19:34:35 ECONOMIC RECOVERY PACKAGE IN OUR HISTORY. SO THE BUDGET 19:34:38 INCLUDED $4 BILLION IN GRANTS FOR THE INSTALL BUSINESS 19:34:42 -COVID-19 RELIEF PROGRAM. NOW, I WAS ABLE 19:34:46 TO PARTNER WITH GOBIS AND THE 19:34:49 SMALL BUSINESS MAJORITY AND HAD A WORKSHOP EARLY ON TO 19:34:53 HELP SPREAD THE WORD ABOUT THE PROGRAM. WE'VE NOW COMPLETED NINE 19:34:56 ROUNDS AND SENT DISTRICT 19:34:59 10, 4500 COMPANIES RECEIVED 19:35:03 ROUGHLY $50 MILLION IN GRANTS. NOT LOANS, JUST 19:35:06 GRANTS THAT WE GAVE THEM TO TRY TO HELP THEM STAY IN BUSINESS. 19:35:10 OTHER AREAS FOCUSING ON EQUITY 19:35:13 INCLUDED TWICE, EXTENDING THE EVICTION MORATORIUM WHICH NOW 19:35:16 HAS EXPIRED, EXPANDING ACCESS 19:35:19 TO AFFORDABLE HEALTH CARE AND AFFORDABLE HIGHER EDUCATION, 19:35:23 INCREASING THE NUMBER OF CHILDCARE SPOTS BY 200,000 19:35:26 SLOTS. AND A $6 BILLION INVESTMENT 19:35:29 IN BROADBAND TO IMPROVE BROADBAND INFRASTRUCTURE 19:35:32 IN UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES AND REDUCED THE DIGITAL DIVIDE 19:35:35 . WE KNOW THERE ARE MANY OF OUR STUDENTS HERE THAT JUST DON'T 19:35:39 HAVE ACCESS TO BROADBAND IN THEIR HOME. AND FINALLY, 19:35:42 WE PITCHED IN $2 BILLION TO COVER PAST- 19:35:45 DUE WATER AND UTILITY BILLS. NOW WE DID MAKE 19:35:48 THIS HISTORIC $15 19:35:51 BILLION CLIMATE PACKAGE AND THAT INCLUDED $3 19:35:55 .7 BILLION FOR CLIMATE RESILIENCY, $ 19:35:58 4.6 BILLION IN WATER AND DROUGHT RELIEF, $1 19:36:02 $1.1 BILLION IN REDUCING 19:36:05 AGRICULTURAL IMPACTS, $140 MILLION TO 19:36:08 BEGIN CIRCULAR ECONOMY AND RECYCLING ISSUES, 19:36:11 AND 3.9 BILLION FOR ZERO EMISSION VEHICLES 19:36:14 . NOW I HELPED LEAD NEGOTIATION IN THE 19:36:18 EARLY WILDFIRE DEAL PROVIDING OVER HALF A 19:36:21 BILLION DOLLARS EARLY OFTEN FOR WILDFIRE PREVENTION, 19:36:24 HOME HARDENING AND FIRE BRICKS AND OTHER ASSISTANCE 19:36:27 ASSISTANCE. IN ALL THE STATE THIS YEAR IS 19:36:30 INVESTING $1.5 BILLION ON WILDFIRE 19:36:34 PREVENTION. A DECADE AGO, WE WERE DOING NOTHING BECAUSE OF 19:36:37 THE PROBLEMS WITH THE BUDGET. WE'RE EXTENDING 19:36:40 THE GREENHOUSE GAS FUND COMMITMENT TO 19:36:43 PROVIDE $200 MILLION AS A MINIMUM IN 19:36:47 SB 901 WILDFIRES THROUGH BUDGET YEAR 2028 AND 19:36:50 2029. THIS BIG CHANGE IS IN THE 19:36:53 AMOUNT IS GOING TO BE TAKEN OFF THE TOP SO IT'S PART OF THE 60 19:36:57 % WITH HIGH SPEED 19:37:00 RAIL AND THAT. AND WHAT THAT DOES IS IT FREEZE UP 19:37:03 , THAT FORMULA FREEZE UP ANOTHER $130 19:37:06 MILLION ANNUALLY FOR DISCRETIONARY FUNDINGS IN THE BUDGET 19:37:09 AND OVER SIX YEARS THAT'S GOING TO BE $7 19:37:13 80 MILLION WHICH THE LEGISLATURE'S IN THEIR DISCRETION 19:37:16 CAN SPEND ON WORTHY GRATION REDUCE 19:37:21 GREENHOUSE GAS EMISSIONS PROGRAMS. 19:37:24 WE ARE MAKING HUGE, WHEN IT COMES TO TRANSITION 19:37:27 ING AMERICANS TO ZERO EMISSION VEHICLES TO CUT 19:37:30 THE GREENHOUSE GAS EAPPLICATIONS AS FREMONT 19:37:33 HAS BEEN DOING IN THE TRANSPORTATION 19:37:36 SECTOR. IT IS 18% OF OUR EAPPLICATIONS IN 19:37:40 CALIFORNIA, WE'RE AWARE OF THE 40% SHARE THAT TRANSPORTATION 19:37:43 HAS IN TOTAL EMISSIONS. SO WE'VE -- THIS YEAR 19:37:46 WE'VE PUT $525 MILLION 19:37:49 INTO THE VEHICLE REBATE PROGRAM, WHICH IS 19:37:52 AN EXTREMELY POPULAR PROGRAM FOR PEOPLE BUYING NEW CARS 19:37:55 AND EVERY YEAR IT RUNS OUT OF MONEY. WE'RE ALSO INVESTING 19:37:59 IN ZERO EMISSION VEHICLE TRANSIT 19:38:03 , CLEAN TRUCKS, AND Z 19:38:06 EB SCHOOL BUSES AS WELL AS IS CHARGING AND FUELING 19:38:09 INFRASTRUCTURE TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF ZEB VEHICLES 19:38:13 IN CALIFORNIA. NOW, LOCALLY, I'VE WORKED 19:38:16 WITH SEVERAL -- ON SEVERAL PROJECTS 19:38:19 IN THE BUDGET AND THE EAST BAY REGIONAL PARK DISTRICT 19:38:22 IS SEFTION $10 MILLION AND ALSO SOME EQUIPMENT THAT THEY ARE 19:38:26 GETTING, TO HELP 19:38:29 THEM FIGHT WILDFIRES IN THE AREA, 19:38:33 THE CONSERVANCY IS GETTING 19:38:36 $FIVE MILLION AND THE ALAMEDA COUNTY FLOOD CONTROL 19:38:39 DISTRICT IS GETTING MORE 19:38:43 MONEY FOR ALAMEDA AND MISSION CREEK 19:38:46 , MISSION CREEK RUNS INTO STIVE 19:38:50 ERS LAGOON. IT WAS 19:38:53 MY PLEASURE TO TEAM UP WITH ASSEMBLY MEMBER QUIRK TO GET 19:38:56 YOU THAT 7.2 THAT YOU NEEDED ON THIS MISSION 19:38:59 BOULEVARD, I-680. THAT'S WHAT OUR 19:39:03 JOBS ARE, TO MAKE SURE THE NEEDS OF THE CITIES ARE MET. 19:39:06 IN ADDITION TO THAT FREMONT IS GOING TO SEE IS 2. 19:39:09 1 MILLION THAT IS GOING TO COME INTO THE STIVE 19:39:13 STIVERS LAGOON TO RESTORE THE NATURE 19:39:17 AREA IN THE PARK, YOU'VE GOT 2.9 19:39:20 MILLION TO WORK ON THE PANHANDLE PARK 19:39:23 WHICH IS ADJACENT TO 19:39:27 LAKE ELIZABETH ON GRIMMER, TO EXTEND THE 19:39:30 ACCESS TO BICYCLES, THE CALIFORNIA 19:39:34 ARE HISTORIC PARK IS GOING TO RECEIVE $2 MILLION FOR 19:39:37 UPGRADINGS THE VISITOR CENTERS AND 19:39:40 RESTORING THE PRESIDENT'S HOUSE IN THE NILES DISTRICT AND 19:39:43 $5 MILLION HAS BEEN AWARDED TO THE 19:39:46 MASS SCIENCE NUCLEUS HERE IN FREMONT TO REFURBISH 19:39:49 THEIR FACILITY WHICH HOUSES THE CHILDREN'S LOCAL 19:39:52 NATURAL HISTORY MUSEUM. SO 19:39:56 THAT'S HOW FREMONT SPECIFICALLY IS BENEFITED 19:39:59 . LASTLY, LET ME GIVE YOU A BRIEF ROUNDUP OF 19:40:02 MY LEGISLATIVE AGENDA. FORTUNATELY THE GOVERNOR SIGNED 19:40:06 ALL THE BILLS THAT WERE PLACED ON HIS DESK THIS YEAR AND IT 19:40:10 INCLUDES, YOU KNOW, A CONTINUED COMMITMENT TO GROVING 19:40:13 THE STRONG CONSUMER PROTECTIONS THAT 19:40:17 CALIFORNIANS DESERVE AND WHAT I THINK THEY EXPECT FROM 19:40:20 THEIR REPRESENTATIVES. IT EXPANDS TRANSPARENCY ON 19:40:24 WORKER AND CONSUMER RIGHTS AT A TIME WHEN MANY 19:40:27 PEOPLE QUITE FRANKLY ARE STRUGGLING AND SOME 19:40:30 CORPORATION ARE TRYING TO TIP THE SCALES EVEN FURTHER IN THEIR 19:40:33 FAVOR. SO SENATE BILL 274 WHICH WAS SUPPORTED BY 19:40:36 THE CALIFORNIA NEWSPAPER PUBLISHERS AND THE CALIFORNIA 19:40:40 TAXPAYERS ASSOCIATION WILL NOW ALLOW FREMONT TO SEND 19:40:43 OUT ELECTRONIC PACKETS TO MEMBERS OF THE PUBLIC WHO 19:40:45 REQUEST THEM. BEFORE THAT THE REQUIREMENTS 19:40:48 WERE THAT YOU HAD TO ACTUALLY SEND PAPER PACKETS TO PEOPLE AND 19:40:52 SOMETIMES THEY WOULDN'T ARRIVE UNTIL AFTER THE ACTUAL HEARING 19:40:55 . AND THIS IS OBVIOUSLY, WHEN 19:40:59 THE CITIZEN REQUESTS IT. INTE 19:41:02 531 REQUIRES COLLECTORS OF A DEBT THAT WAS 19:41:05 ASSIGNED TO THEM, NOT A DEBT THAT THEY SOLD 19:41:08 BUT WAS ASSIGNED TO THEM TO SHOW PROOF THAT 19:41:11 THEY HAVE AUTHORITY TO COLLECT ON THE DEBT. AND THE CONSUMER 19:41:14 PROTECTIONS THAT APPLY TO DEBT THAT IS SOLD WILL 19:41:17 ALSO APPLY IN THIS SO THE DEBTOR HAS PROOF OF THE 19:41:21 BASIC OBLIGATION,FULLY FEES THAT HAVE BEEN 19:41:24 , ANY FEES THAT HAVE 19:41:27 BEEN CHARGED. LEGAL PROVIDERS UP AND DOWN 19:41:31 THE STATE CAME TO ME AND SAID THIS WAS A 19:41:34 PROBLEM, PARTICULARLY CONSUMERS NOT GETTING INFORMATION 19:41:37 ABOUT DEBT THAT WAS THEIRS. I DID A FOLLOW-UP BILL TO THE 19:41:40 BILL I SPONSORED WITH SENATOR HERT 19:41:44 ZBERG SB 19:41:47 707 BACK IN 2019, THIS IS 19:41:50 SB 702 AND THIS BASICALLY ENSURES THAT ASH DURATION 19:41:53 COMPANIES, SOMETIMES THE ARBITRATION COMPANIES WOULD NOT SEND THE INFORMATION 19:41:57 THAT SOMEBODY HAS FILED A COMPLAINT AND ASKED THE 19:42:00 COMPANY OR THE CREDITOR 19:42:03 TO PAY THEIR FEES. AND THAT NEVER STARTED THE PROCESS. 19:42:06 SO PEOPLE WOULD SIT IN LIMBO. SO WE'VE 19:42:09 GOT LANGUAGE NOW THAT WILL PREVENT THEM FROM CIRCUMVENT 19:42:12 ING THE CAUSE AND IF THEY 19:42:16 DON'T PAY THEIR FEES THEN THE MATTER WILL GO TO 19:42:19 SUPREME COURT AND PEOPLE WILL GET A JUDGMENT AGAINST FOLKS. 19:42:22 OTHER BILLS THAT WERE SIGNED WILL STRENGTHEN THE DEPARTMENT OF 19:42:25 FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING'S ABILITY TO 19:42:28 PREVENT DISCRIMINATION IN SENATE BILL 8 19:42:31 807 AND HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION'S 19:42:35 BANK STAPLES ARE NOW PART OF THE SENATE REPORTS IN 19:42:38 SB 402 AND FOR ALL THE ELECTRIC VEHICLE 19:42:42 AND AUTONOMOUS VEHICLE FOLKS SB 5 19:42:45 72 CHANGES OUR VEHICLE CODES SO YOU DON'T NEED A 19:42:48 MUFFLER ON AN ELECTRIC VEHICLE, YOU DON'T 19:42:52 NEED REARVIEW MIRRORS ON AN 19:42:57 AUTONOMOUS VEHICLE, WE'VE GOT AN UPDATE ON 19:43:00 THAT ON SB 570. I'VE EXTEND 19:43:03 ED ON TOW 19:43:07 ING, IF A PERSON WAS A 19:43:10 MINOR FOR LESS THAN SIX MONTHS IN SB 501 19:43:13 , I HAVE REQUIRING PUBLIC OWNED UTILITIES, 19:43:16 LIKE SANTA CLARA AND ALAMEDA, CITY OWNS 19:43:19 UTILITIES, TO PROVIDE FOR ALL THEIR TRANSPORTATION ELECTRIFICATION 19:43:23 , INCLUDING LIGHT, MEDIUM AND HEAVY DUTY AND OFF 19:43:26 AND ON-ROAD VEHICLES IN THEIR INTEGRATED RESOURCES PLAN 19:43:29 IN SB 437. THERE WAS ANOTHER BILL THAT WE DIDN'T MOVE 19:43:32 . IT WAS ACTUALLY BECAME PART OF THE BUDGET DEALING 19:43:35 . INSTEAD IT WAS LONGS OVERDUE REFORMS FOR 19:43:38 OUR TROUBLED DEPARTMENT OF TOXIC SUBSTANCE CONTROL. 19:43:42 THESE REFORMS WILL 19:43:45 INCREASE OVERSIGHT AND STABILIZE THE THE 19:43:48 FUNDING THAT GOES INTO THE DEPARTMENT SO THEY CAN 19:43:52 TRACK DOWN ON POLLUTERS AND HOLD THE 19:43:55 POLLUTERS ACCOUNTABLE. ALSO CREATES FUNDING TO 19:43:58 CLEAN UP FUNDS ON BROWN FIELD SO EXCEPT TO 19:44:01 RECEIVE THAT. I'LL JUST CONCLUDE, I HAVE ONE 19:44:04 LAST ANNOUNCEMENT I'M GOING TO BE DOING AT THURSDAY 19:44:08 OCTOBER 28th AT 6 P.M. I WILL BE 19:44:11 HOSTING MY VIRTUAL STATE OF THE DISTRICT ARREST AND 19:44:14 MY AWARDS CEREMONIES. I GET TO 19:44:18 HIGHLIGHT ORGANIZATIONS THAT ARE DOING GOOD WORK HERE 19:44:21 . WE'LL POST THAT ZOOM RECORDING VIEWING ON MY WEBSITE. 19:44:24 AND LET ME ONE JUST CONGRATULATE THE CITY FOR 19:44:28 THE GREENNESS OF THE CITY, 19:44:31 IN THE 2021 BEACON VANGUARD PLATINUM 19:44:34 AWARD THAT WE'VE JUST HEARD FROM THE INSTITUTE OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT. 19:44:37 AND THAT CONCLUDES MY UPDATE AT THIS TIME. I'D LOVE 19:44:41 TO TAKE ANY QUESTIONS AND JUST THANK YOU ALL FOR THE OPPORTUNITY 19:44:44 TO SPEAK TONIGHT. 19:44:51 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU, SENATOR WIECKOWSKI. 19:44:54 I WANTED TO SEE FIRST DID THERE ARE ANY 19:44:57 QUESTIONS FROM MY COUNCILMEMBERS TON LEGISLATIVE 19:45:00 CAN POLICIES. I'M SURE SENATOR WIECKOWSKI IS 19:45:04 READY TO ANSWER THIS. SEEING NONE I WANTED TO OPEN 19:45:06 THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD. IF THERE ARE ANY PUBLIC COMMENTS 19:45:09 OR QUESTIONS ON THIS. OKAY 19:45:13 . AND IF YOU WANTED TO SPEAK PLEASE DO SO 19:45:16 BY PRESSING RAISE HAND ICON. SEEING NONE 19:45:19 , I'M GOING TO CLOSE THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD. 19:45:23 19:45:26 AND I JUST WANTED TO SAY AGAIN WE ARE VERY 19:45:29 GRATEFUL SENATOR WIECKOWSKI FOR HAVING YOU HERE TONIGHT AND APPRECIATE 19:45:32 HEARING YOUR UPDATE. FOR OUR COMMUNITY WE DISCUSS OUR 19:45:35 CITY'S GUIDING LEGISLATIVE PRINCIPLES AND PRIORITIES AS 19:45:38 A COUNCIL EVERY YEAR. AND LATE WINTER 19:45:42 AND EARLY SPRING AS PARTS OF OUR RETREAT DISCUSSIONS 19:45:45 . AND IF YOU'RE INTERESTED IN HEARING MORE OR LEARNING MORE 19:45:48 ABOUT OUR CITY'S LEGISLATIVE PRIORITIES AND WORK, 19:45:51 PLEASE VISIT WWW.FREMONT 19:45:56 .GOV/ 19:46:00 WWW.FREMONT.GOV/LEGISLATIVE 19:46:03 AFFAIRS. SO THANK YOU 19:46:09 SENATOR WIECKOWSKI AGAIN FOR YOUR TIME AND WE APPRECIATE YOU. 19:46:12 HAVE A WONDERFUL EVENING, PLEASE SAY HI 19:46:15 TO SUE AND THE FAMILY. 19:46:19 THEM ON OUR AGENDA ITEM THIS EVENING 19:46:22 IS BACK TO OUR REGULARLY SKILLED ITEM WHICH 19:46:26 SCELGD 19:46:29 SCHEDULED ITEM ITEM 5A 19:46:32 OUR AFFORDABLE HOUSING UPDATE. THIS EVENING I WANTED TO WELCOME 19:46:36 WELCOME, WE HAVE HOUSING MANAGER, LUCIA 19:46:39 HUGHES AS WELL AS OUR COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DIRECTOR, WHO YOU HEARD 19:46:43 FROM EARLIER, 19:46:46 DAN 19:46:49 SCHOENHOLZ WHO WILL BE SHARING A PRESENTATION TODAY 19:46:52 . >> Dan Schoenholz: THANK YOU, MAYOR MEI. 19:46:55 I'M HERE WITH LUCIA HUGHES THE CITY'S HOUSING 19:46:59 MANAGER, WHO WILL BE PROVIDING A PRESENTATION ON 19:47:02 THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING 19:47:06 ORDINANCE. DAVID DO 19:47:09 ZEMA 19:47:12 THE 19:47:27 THE KEYSER-MARSTON REPRESENTATIVE. WE WILL GO THROUGH THE REVISIONS 19:47:31 BEING PROPOSED AND THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S RECOMMENDATIONS. 19:47:34 OUR GOAL TONIGHT IS FOR COUNCIL TO ADOPT THE 19:47:36 UPDATE TO THE ORDINANCE. NEXT SLIDE. 19:47:45 IN 2019, COUNCIL DIRECTED STAFF TO 19:47:49 INITIATE AN UPDATE TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING 19:47:51 ORDINANCE WITH THE FOLLOWING GOALS IN MIND. 19:47:54 TO INCREASE RESOURCES FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING, 19:47:57 TO REFLECT COURT DECISIONS AND CHANGES IN STATE LAW 19:48:00 , THAT AFFIRM THE CITY'S ABILITY TO REQUIRE 19:48:03 AN AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMPONENT IN BOTH RENTAL AND FOR- 19:48:07 SALE PROJECTS, AND TO CLARIFY 19:48:10 AND SIMPLIFY THE ORDINANCE WHERE WE COULD. 19:48:13 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 19:48:17 AS A FIRST STEP IN THE UPDATE PROCESS, WE COMMISSIONED 19:48:21 A NEXUS STUDY AND A FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY STUDY TO GET A 19:48:24 SENSE FOR WHAT LEVEL OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING REQUIREMENTS ARE 19:48:27 RELATED TO NEW DEVELOPMENT AND CAN FEASIBLY BE CHARGED 19:48:30 . THEN WE HELD A STAKEHOLDER MEETING, AND WORK 19:48:33 SESSIONS WITH THE COMMISSION 19:48:37 , AND THE COUNCIL TO PRESENT THESE STUDIES. 19:48:40 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 19:48:45 AT THE COUNCIL WORK SESSION WE GOT CLEAR DIRECTION THAT COUNCIL WANTED TO 19:48:48 RETAIN THE ABILITY FOR DEVELOPERS TO PAY FEES IN LIEU OF 19:48:51 PROVIDING ONSITE UNITS SINCE FEES CAN 19:48:55 SUBSIDIZE PRODUCTION OF LOWER-INCOME RENTAL UNITS 19:48:58 . COUNCIL ALSO SUPPORTED INCREASING FEE LEVELS TO 19:49:02 THE EXTENT FEASIBLE TO INCREASE THE RESOURCE 19:49:05 S AVAILABLE FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING PRODUCTION. COUNCIL SUPPORTED A 19:49:08 PHASE-IN OF A REQUIREMENT TO 19:49:11 GIVE THE MARKET TIME TO ADJUST. COUNCIL ALSO 19:49:14 WANTED US TO RETAIN THE VARIETY OF OPTIONS THAT EXIST 19:49:17 IN THE CURRENTS ORDINANCE, FOR EXAMPLE, 19:49:21 LAND DONATIONS. YOU WANTED TO CONTINUE 19:49:24 TO INCENTIVIZE SMALLER MARKET RATE RENTAL UNITS 19:49:27 BY DISCOUNTING FEES ON THOSE UNITS AND FINALLY 19:49:30 COUNCIL DIRECTED US TO SIMPLIFY AND CLARIFY THE 19:49:33 ORDINANCE WHEREVER WE COULD. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 19:49:39 JUSTING THAT DIRECTION AS WELL AS INFORMATION FROM THE TECHNICAL STUDIES 19:49:43 AND ALSO OUR EXPERIENCE IN ADMINISTERING THE CURRENT ORDINANCE 19:49:46 WE DRAFTED A REVISED ORDINANCE. WE SHARED THAT 19:49:49 REVISED ORDINANCE AT A STAKEHOLDER MEETING THIS 19:49:52 PAST JULY AND THEN BROUGHT IT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION 19:49:55 IN AUGUST. THE PLANNING COMMISSION VOTED 19:49:59 UNANIMOUSLY THAT COUNCIL ADOPT THE REVISED 19:50:02 WORNS ONE CHANGE TO THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION THAT WE'LL DESCRIBE 19:50:05 LATER IN THE PRESENTATION. NEXT SLIDE. 19:50:08 SO WITH THAT BY WAY OF BACKGROUND, WE NOW WOULD 19:50:11 LIKE TO WALK YOU THROUGH THE PROPOSED REVISIONS 19:50:14 TO THE ORDINANCE. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 19:50:18 AS WE DISCUSSED AT THE WORK SESSION WITH COUNCIL, 19:50:21 THERE ARE TWO MAIN OPTIONS UNDER THE CURRENT ORDINANCE 19:50:24 . MARKET RATE DEVELOPERS CAN EITHER BUILD INCLUSION 19:50:27 ARY UNITS, OR THEY CAN PAY WHAT WE CALL AN 19:50:31 IN LIEU FEE. AND ONE IMPORTANT CHANGE 19:50:34 WE ARE PROPOSING IS TO INCREASE THE IN LIEU 19:50:38 FEES ON FOR SALE TOWN HOMES AND SINGLE 19:50:41 FAMILY HOMES FROM THE CURRENT LEVEL OF 19:50:44 26 OR $27 PER SQUARE FOOT, UP 19:50:48 TO $44 PER SQUARE FOOT. 19:50:51 WE ARE PROPOSING $44 PER 19:50:54 SQUARE FOOT BECAUSE THE FEASIBILITY STUDY FOUND THAT TO BE THE 19:50:57 MAXIMUM FEE THAT COULD BE CHARGED ON SINGLE 19:51:00 FAMILY HOMES WITHOUT SUPPRESSING DEVELOPMENT 19:51:04 . THE CONSULTANT FOUND THAT $50 PER SQUARE FOOT 19:51:07 COULD BE CHARGED OR COULD BE SUPPORTED BY TOWN HOMES. 19:51:10 BUT STAFF IS PROPOSING TO HAVE 19:51:13 A SINGLE FEE OF $44 FOR 19:51:17 ADMINISTRATIVE ASSEMBLIESITY AND ALSO THE 19:51:20 $44 FEE WOULD BE HIGHER THAN ANY 19:51:24 OF THE FEES CHARGED IN THE NEIGHBORING CITIES. WE'LL SEE THE CHANGE 19:51:27 IN THIS LATER BUT THE ONE STAFF TO THE RECOMMENDATION 19:51:31 THAT PLANNING COMMISSION IS RECOMMENDING IS A HIGHER MAXIMUM IN LIEU FEE 19:51:34 . I WOULD NOTE THAT WE ARE NOT RECOMMENDING ANY 19:51:38 INCREASE TO STACKED FLAT OR 19:51:41 EQUILIBRIUM OWNERSHIP 19:51:49 CONDOMINIUM PROJECTS MANY SINCE THE FEE LEVEL 19:51:52 WAS INFEASIBLE. I WOULD ALSO NOTE THAT PER COUNCIL DIRECTION 19:51:55 TO PHASE IN THE NEW FEES WE'RE PROPOSING TO IMPLEMENT 19:51:58 THE FEES INCREASE IN TWO STEPS. THE FIRST 19:52:02 STEP WOULD START ON THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE NEW FEE, THROUGH THE END 19:52:05 OF 2022. WITH THE SECOND INCREASE 19:52:08 GOING INTO EFFECT ON JANUARY 1, 2023. 19:52:12 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 19:52:16 FOR RENTAL PROJECTS WE ARE NOT PROPOSING A FEE 19:52:20 INCREASE. THE FEASIBILITY STUDY INDICATED 19:52:23 THAT THE ONLY RENTAL PROJECTS THAT COULD FEASIBLY PAY AN 19:52:27 INCREASED FEE WERE THOSE IN CLOSE PRPLTD TO 19:52:30 PROXIMITY TO 19:52:34 A TRANSIT STATION. WHERE WE WANT TO ACCOMMODATE 19:52:38 MUCH OF OUR FUTURE HOUSING NEED, 19:52:41 STAFF'S REGISTERS IS TO LEAVE THE CURRENT 19:52:44 RENTAL FEE UNCHANGED. WE ARE PROPOSING TO RETAIN THE 19:52:48 DISCOUNTED FEES FOR SMALLER RENTAL UNITS BECAUSE 19:52:51 THOSE UNITS TEND TO BE MORE AFFORDABLE BY DESIGN. 19:52:55 RENTAL PROJECTS THAT HAVE A SUBDIVISION MAP ON 19:52:58 THEM AND CAN THEREFORE BE QURTED TO OWNERSHIP PROJECTS 19:53:01 WITHOUT CITY 19:53:04 PROOIVELZ, PAY THE 19:53:07 SAME FEE AS STACKED DPLATS AND WE'RE NOT PROPOSING 19:53:10 TO CHANGE THAT IN THE ORDINANCE. 19:53:14 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. THE SECOND MAJOR CHANGE THAT 19:53:17 WE ARE PROPOSING IS THE PERCENTAGE REQUIRED IF THE 19:53:20 DEVELOPER CHOOSE TO MEET THE 19:53:24 REQUIREMENT ENTIRELY BY BUILDING INCLUSION 19:53:27 ARY UNITS. THE 19:53:32 RANGES RANGE FROM 18% TO 26% 19:53:35 AS SHOWN ON THE SLIDE. HOWEVER NO DEVELOPER LAST EVER 19:53:38 CHOSEN THIS OPTION AND BASED ON THE FEEDBACK THAT WE'VE GOTTEN 19:53:41 , THAT'S BECAUSE OF THE PERCENTAGE 19:53:45 REQUIRED RELATIVELY HIGH PERCENTAGE OF 19:53:49 INCLUSIONARY UNITS REQUIRED AS WELL AS THE REQUIREMENT THIS 19:53:52 THESE UNITS BE MADE AFFORDABLE TO EXTREMELY LOW 19:53:55 INCOME HOUSEHOLDS WHO MAKE 30% OF LESS 19:53:58 OF THE MEDIAN INCOME AND VERY LOW INCOME BUYERS WHO EARN 19:54:01 50% OR LESS OF MEDIAN INCOME. 19:54:05 SO WE'RE PROPOSING TO REVISE THE REQUIREMENT TO 19:54:08 BE 15% INCLUSIONARY UNITS, 19:54:12 WITH 5% AFFORDABLE TO MODERATE INCOME BUYERS 19:54:15 AND 10% TO LOW INCOME BUYERS. 19:54:18 THAT 15% REQUIREMENT FOCUSED ON LOW AND MODERATE 19:54:22 INCOME BUYERS IS FAIRLY COMMON AMONG BAY AREA CITIES. 19:54:26 SO THIS WOULD BETTER ALIGN US WITH OTHER CITIES. 19:54:29 AND WOULD ALSO INCREASE THE LIKELIHOOD 19:54:33 THAT DEVELOPERRERS WOULD LIKELY PRODUCE SOME INCLUSIONARY 19:54:36 UNITS. FOR RENTAL PROJECTS WE'RE PROPOSING A 19:54:40 10% INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENT TARGETED AT LOW INCOME 19:54:43 RESIDENTS. BECAUSE THE FEASIBILITY STUDY 19:54:46 INDICATES ONLY A 5% LOW INCOME REQUIREMENT IS FEASIBLE 19:54:49 FOR RENTAL PROJECTS, STAFF BELIEVES 19:54:53 THAT RENTAL DEVELOPERS WILL CHOOSE TO TAKE THE 19:54:56 PAY THE IN LIEU FEE IN THE SHORT TERM 19:55:00 . HOWEVER IN THE MEDIUM OR LONG TERM 19:55:03 MARKET CONDITIONS CAN CHANGE AND INCLUSIONARY UNITS CAN BECOME 19:55:06 A REALISTIC OPTION FOR 19:55:09 RENTAL DEVELOPERS AND HAVING THE 10% IN PLACE WOULD 19:55:13 RESULT IN MORE NUMBER OF LOW INCOME 19:55:16 UNITS IN THAT SCENARIO. THE FULL IN LIEU FEE AND 19:55:19 THE INCLUSIONARY OPTION CHANGES THAT I'VE 19:55:22 JUST DESCRIBED ARE THE TWO MAIN REVISIONS IN THE ORDINANCE 19:55:25 . HOWEVER, PER COUNCIL DIRECTION WE'RE RETAINING 19:55:28 THE VARIOUS OTHER OPTIONS THAT ARE PROVIDED 19:55:32 IN THE CURRENT ORDINANCE WITH A COUPLE OF PROPOSED CHANGES 19:55:35 . SO NEXT SLIDE. 19:55:41 ONE OF THE OPTIONS IN THE ORDINANCE IS WHAT WE CALL THE HYBRID 19:55:44 OPTION. THIS OPTION ALLOWS THE DEVELOPER TO BUILD MODERATE 19:55:48 INCOME INCLUSIONARY UNITS WHILE PAYING A FEE 19:55:52 IN LIEU OF BUILDING LOW INCOME INCLUSIONARY 19:55:55 UNITS. SECOND COLUMN IN THE CHART SHOWS 19:55:58 THE CURRENT COMBINATION 19:56:01 ONSITE AND IN LIEU FEE REQUIREMENT. 19:56:04 UNDER THE PROPOSED OPTION, DEVELOPERS OF SINGLE 19:56:07 FAMILY HOMES OR TOWN HOMES EXERCISING THIS HYBRID 19:56:10 OPTION WOULD BE REQUIRED TO BUILD 5% MODERATE INCOME 19:56:14 UNITS ON SITE SO THAT'S A SLIGHT INCREASE FROM THE CURRENT 19:56:16 ORDINANCE. AND PAY IN LIEU FEES THAT WOULD 19:56:19 BE PHASED IN, IN TWO STEPS. ULTIMATELY TOPPING OUT 19:56:23 AT $29 PER SQUARE FOOT. 19:56:26 FOR STACKED FLATS, WE'RE PROPOSING ALSO 19:56:29 A 5% INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENT, 19:56:33 FOR MODERATE INCOME, AND AN 19:56:36 IN LIEU FEE OF $12 PER SQUARE FOOT DURING THE 19:56:39 LIFE OF THE ORDINANCE. THE FEASIBILITY STUDY HAS 19:56:42 CONCLUDED THAT A HIGHER FEE FOR STACKED FLATS IS IN 19:56:45 FEASIBLE. THE FEE SAVINGS REALIZED BY 19:56:49 THIS EXERCISING THE HYBRID OPTION 19:56:52 WORKS OUT TO O 19:56:56 $15 PER SQUARE FOOT BASED ON THE CITY'S 19:56:59 ECONOMIC CONSULTANT THAT $15 PER SQUARE FOOT IS 19:57:03 APPROXIMATELY EQUIVALENT TO TO PROVIDING THE 15% MODERATE 19:57:07 INCOME UNITS. NEXT SUPPLIED PLEASE 19:57:11 . THERE IS ALSO AN OPTION IN THE CURRENT ORDINANCE THAT 19:57:14 ALLOWS A DEVELOPER OF FOR 19:57:17 SALE HOUSING TO FULFILL 19:57:20 THEIR OBLIGATION FOR FOR SALE UNITS BY PROVIDING 19:57:25 AFFORDABLE UNITS. THIS IS WHEN IT PROVIDES A 19:57:28 FOR SALE AND RENTAL UNIT. IN THE CURRENT ORDINANCE 19:57:32 THE REQUIREMENT IS FOR 13.4% OF UNITS TO BE AFFORDABLE 19:57:35 . 19:57:38 AGAIN DIVIDED UP AMONG 19:57:42 FOUR DIFFERENT INCOME LEVELS, STAFF'S RECOMMENDATION IS 19:57:46 TO RAISE TO 15% AND FOCUS ON LOW INCOME 19:57:49 AND VERY LOW INCOME UNITS. WITH THAT I'LL TURN IT OVER 19:57:52 TO OUR HOUSING MANAGER, LUCIA HUGHES AND LUCIA 19:57:55 WILL WALK YOU THROUGH SOME OF THE OTHER PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE 19:57:59 ORDINANCE. DISCUSS THE INPUT 19:58:02 THAT WE GOT FROM STAKEHOLDERS, THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S 19:58:05 RECOMMENDATION AND THEN SUMMARIZE STAFF'S 19:58:07 RECOMMENDATIONS BEFORE WE OPEN IT UP TO THE COUNCIL FOR 19:58:11 QUESTIONS. LUCIA. >> THANK YOU DAN 19:58:14 . NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 19:58:22 NEXT SLIDE, APPLIES. THANK YOU 19:58:25 . THANK YOU DAN, GOOD EVENING, MAYOR MEI, 19:58:28 VICE MAYOR SHAO, AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL. WE WANT TO 19:58:31 TOUCH ON SOME CLARIFICATIONS AND MINOR 19:58:34 CHANGES PROPOSED BY STAFF AS A RESULT OF 19:58:38 CHALLENGES AND LESSONS LEARNED FROM THE ADMINISTRATION OF THE 19:58:41 CURRENT ORDINANCE. 19:58:44 CAN YOU GO BACK TO ONE SLIDE PLEASE 19:58:48 ALBERTO? THE TIMING, THANK YOU 19:58:51 . TIMING AND PERFORMANCE FOR PROJECTS THAT INCLUDE ON 19:58:54 SITE MARKET RATE AND AFFORDABLE UNITS, STAFF WANTS TO 19:58:57 CLARIFY THAT THE CONSTRUCTION TIMING AND OCCUPANCY OF THE 19:59:03 AFFORDABLE UNITS 19:59:06 SHOULD BE TIMING OF THE 19:59:09 APPROVAL BODIES, DETERMINES THAT GREATER 19:59:13 PUBLIC BENEFITS WOULD RESULT FROM THE 19:59:16 MODIFICATION. IN THIS CASE, THE 19:59:19 CITY MAY REQUIRE THAT THE COMPLETION 19:59:23 OF AFFORDABLE UNITS BE FURTHER SECURED BY THE APPLICANT 19:59:26 AGREEMENT TO PAY THE IN-LIEU FEES. 19:59:29 THIS WOULD ENSURE THAT THE PROJECT WILL 19:59:32 PAY THE IN-LIEU FEE OWED TO THE CITY 19:59:36 IN THE EVENT THERE ARE CHANGES OR PROBLEMS WITH THE DEVELOPMENTS 19:59:40 . THE CITY'S AFFORDABLE HOUSING INTEREST WOULD BE PROTECTED 19:59:44 . NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. ANOTHER 19:59:48 CHANGE THAT STAFF WANTS TO MAKE IS TO FURTHER CLARIFY 19:59:51 THE REQUIREMENTS, IF AN APPLICANT DESIRES TO MODIFY 19:59:55 THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLAN AFTER 19:59:58 PROJECT APPROVAL. AN APPLICATION FOR THE FIRST 20:00:01 APPROVAL OF A RESIDENTIAL PROJECT INCLUDES AN 20:00:05 AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLAN, DESCRIBING HOW THE PROJECT WILL 20:00:08 COMPLY WITH THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING ORDINANCE. 20:00:11 BECAUSE THE ORIGINAL AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLAN MAY 20:00:15 HAVE INFLUENCED THE APPROVAL BODY'S 20:00:18 DECISION ON APPROVING THE PROJECT, STAFF IS 20:00:21 PROPOSING THAT MODIFICATIONS TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING 20:00:25 PLAN, AFTER PROJECT APPROVAL, WOULD NEED TO BE 20:00:28 REVIEWED BY THE APPROVAL BODY. 20:00:32 ANY PROPOSED AMENDMENTS TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING PLAN MUST BE APPROVED ABOUT 20:00:35 WHICH THE APPROVAL BODY PRIOR TO BUILDING PERMIT ISSUANCE 20:00:38 . NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 20:00:46 THIS CONCLUDES THE PROPOSED REVISIONS SECTION OF THE PRESENTATION 20:00:50 . WE BELIEVE THESE PROPOSED REVISIONS WOULD HELP THE 20:00:53 CITY ACHIEVE THE GOAL OF PROMOTING HOUSING 20:00:57 OPPORTUNITIES FOR ALL ECONOMIC SEGMENTS OF 20:01:00 OUR COMMUNITY WITHOUT SUPPRESSING THE CONSTRUCTION 20:01:03 OF MARKET RATE HOUSING. A MORE DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF 20:01:06 ALL OF THE PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE AFFORDABLE HOUSING 20:01:10 ORDINANCE IS INCLUDED IN YOUR AGENDA PACKET 20:01:13 . NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 20:01:17 WE'D LIKE TO SHARE WITH YOU PUBLIC COMMENTS WE 20:01:20 RECEIVED DURING THE ORDINANCE REVISION PROCESS. 20:01:24 STAFF HAS HELD TWO PUBLIC STAKEHOLDER 20:01:28 MEETINGS IN ADDITION TO PRESENTATIONS TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION, 20:01:31 AND CITY COUNCIL. STAKEHOLDERS 20:01:34 INPUT IS SUMMARIZED ON THE SLIDE. IN A 20:01:37 NUTSHELL, MARKET RATE DEVELOPERS WANT THE CITY 20:01:41 TO RETAIN THE FEE OPTION, KEEP 20:01:44 ALL OF THE ALTERNATIVES, MINIMIZE FEE LEVELS 20:01:48 , PHASE IN OF FEE INCREASES, AND 20:01:51 LOWER THE INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENTS 20:01:54 . AFFORDABLE HOUSING ADVOCATES WANT THE CITY TO 20:01:57 INCREASE THE FEES TO THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT FEASIBLE 20:02:02 . ONE COMMUNITY MEMBER WANTS 20:02:05 INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENTS FOR FOR SALE MODERATE INCOME 20:02:09 UNITS WITH NO IN-LIEU FEE OPTIONS. 20:02:12 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 20:02:17 LET'S MOVE ON TO PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDATION. NEXT SLIDE 20:02:21 , PLEASE. 20:02:25 STAFF PRESENTED THE PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE ORDINANCE 20:02:28 AND STAKEHOLDER INPUT TO THE PLANNING COMMISSION AT ITS 20:02:31 AUGUST 26th MEETING. NO PUBLIC COMMENTS WERE 20:02:34 MADE ON THIS ITEM. THE 20:02:38 PLANNING COMMISSION UNANIMOUSLY VOTED TO RECOMMEND COUNCIL APPROVAL 20:02:41 OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS PROPOSED BY STAFF 20:02:44 WITH ONE MODIFICATION THAT WOULD SET THE 20:02:48 MAXIMUM FEE FOR FOR-SALE TOWN HOUSE AND 20:02:51 SINGLE-FAMILY DEVELOPMENTS AT $50 PER SQUARE 20:02:54 FOOT RATHER THAN THE $44 PER SQUARE FOOT RECOMMENDED 20:02:57 BY STAFF. 20:03:00 STAFF CONTINUES TO RECOMMEND TO COUNCIL THAT THE MAXIMUM FEE BE 20:03:03 SET AT $44 PER SQUARE FOOT FOR BOTH TOWN 20:03:07 HOME AND SINGLE FAMILY PROJECTS. ALTHOUGH 20:03:10 THE FEASIBILITY STUDY DETERMINED THAT A $50 20:03:13 PER SQUARE FOOT FEE IS FEASIBLE FOR TOWN 20:03:16 HOME PROJECTS, MAXIMUM PER- 20:03:19 PER-SQUARE-FOOT FEE THAT SINGLE 20:03:21 FAMILY PROJECTS CAN ABSORB IS $44. 20:03:25 ALSO, BY KEEPING THE FEE AT $44 PER SQUARE 20:03:28 FOOT FOR BOTH SINGLE FAMILY HOME AND TOWN 20:03:32 HOME DEVELOPMENT, FREMONT'S MAXIMUM 20:03:35 FEE LEVEL WILL BE CLOSER TO THE MAXIMUM FEE LEVEL OF 20:03:38 OTHER BAY AREA CITIES. NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 20:03:44 TONIGHT WE HAVE EIGHT RECOMMENDATIONS FOR COUNCIL 20:03:47 UNDER THIS ITEM. HOLD PUBLIC HEARING 20:03:50 . FIND THAT THE FEE ADJUSTMENTS ARE EXEMPT FROM 20:03:54 CEQA REVIEW. FIND THAT THE 20:03:57 PROPOSED ZONING TEXT AMENDMENT IS CONSISTENT 20:04:00 WITH THE GENERAL PLAN. FIND THAT THE 20:04:03 ZONING TEXT AMENDMENT FURTHERS THE PUBLIC INTEREST, 20:04:06 CONVENIENCE AND GENERAL WELFARE OF THE CITY 20:04:10 . ADOPT THE FINDINGS CONTAINED IN THE 20:04:14 RESIDENTIAL NEXUS ANALYSIS AND FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY 20:04:17 STUDY. NEXT SLIDE PLEASE 20:04:20 . INTRODUCE AN ORDINANCE APPROVING THE 20:04:23 PROPOSED ZONING TEXT AMENDMENT AS SET FORTH IN THE 20:04:27 DRAFT ORDINANCE. ADOPT A 20:04:31 RESOLUTION APPROVING AN AMENDMENT TO THE MASTER FEE SCHEDULE 20:04:36 REGARDING AFFORDABLE HOUSING FEES AND FINALLY, DIRECT STAFF TO PREPARE AND 20:04:39 THE CITY CLERK TO PUBLISH A SUMMARY OF THE ORDINANCE. 20:04:43 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 20:04:48 THIS SLIDE SUMMARIZES STAFF'S KEY PROPOSED REVISION 20:04:51 S. WE WILL BRING THIS SLIDE BACK UP WHILE YOU 20:04:54 ARE DELIBERATING, SO THAT CAN YOU REFER TO IT 20:05:02 YOU CAN REFER TO IT. NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. THIS CONCLUDES 20:05:06 OUR PRESENTATION. WITH THAT WE'LL OPEN IT UP FOR 20:05:07 QUESTIONS. THANK YOU. 20:05:12 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. I'D LIKE TO TURN THIS BACK TO THE COUNCIL 20:05:17 FOR CLARIFYING QUESTIONS. 20:05:23 SO COUNCILMEMBERS, ARE THERE ANY CLARIFYING QUESTIONS? 20:05:26 WE'LL BEGIN WITH COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN. 20:05:29 >> Councilmember Kassan: YES, I WAS WONDERING WHETHER YOU 20:05:32 KNOW WHY PLANNING COMMISSION RECOMMENDED RAISING 20:05:36 THE FEE, TO THE SAME AMOUNT FOR 20:05:40 BOTH TOWN HOMES AND SINGLE FAMILY PROJECTS 20:05:44 PROJECTS, INSTEAD OF JUST RAISING THE FEE TO $50 20:05:47 PER SQUARE FOOT FOR TOWN HOMES 20:05:51 ? 20:05:58 >> Mayor Mei: STAFF, IS THERE ANY ANSWERS 20:06:01 TO THE QUESTION? 20:06:09 >> THE PLANNING COMMISSION WANTED THE SAME FEE FOR TOWN HOMES 20:06:12 AND SINGLE FAMILY HOME BECAUSE THEY FEEL 20:06:16 THAT MORE FEES WILL HELP THE DEVELOPMENT WITH MORE 20:06:21 AFFORDABLE HOUSING IN A SHORTER TIME PERIOD. BUT 20:06:24 STAFF DID ADVISE THE PLANNING COMMISSION THAT $50 20:06:27 PER SQUARE FOOT FEE IS NOT FEASIBLE FOR SINGLE 20:06:30 FAMILY HOMES. BUT THEY JUST -- THEY STILL WENT AHEAD 20:06:33 WITH THEIR RECOMMENDATION OF $50 PER SQUARE FOOT FEE 20:06:37 FOR BOTH FRO TOE TYPES 20:06:39 . >> Councilmember Kassan: AND IF WE WERE TO VOTE TONIGHT TO 20:06:43 RECOMMEND THE $50 PER SQUARE FOOT 20:06:46 FEE JUST FOR TOWN HOMES BUT KEEP THE $44 20:06:49 FOR THE SINGLE FAMILY, IS THAT -- IS THERE 20:06:52 ANY PROBLEM WITH THAT? >> THERE IS 20:06:55 NOT A PROBLEM WITH THAT. >> Councilmember Kassan: OKAY, 20:06:59 THANK YOU. >> Mayor Mei: OKAY. ANY OTHER 20:07:03 CLARIFYING QUESTIONS AT THIS TIME FROM THE COUNCIL? 20:07:06 SEEING NONE I'LL TURN IT OVER TO -- I'LL 20:07:09 OPEN UP THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD. AND I SEE 20:07:12 WE HAVE A SPEAKER ENDING IN 3 20:07:15 65. 20:07:19 WELCOME. 20:07:28 >> THIS IS ALICE CAF 20:07:31 CAVE 20:07:35 ETTE. WE HAVE TWO SPEAKERS ON THIS TELEPHONE 20:07:38 NUMBER. I'LL GO FIRST. THE 20:07:41 BASIC FOR SALE AFFORDABLE HOUSING IMPACT OBLIGATION 20:07:45 IS INCLUSIONARY ONLY. I ASK THAT 20:07:48 YOU REMOVE THE THE IN LIEU ALTERNATIVE 20:07:51 IN LIEU ALTERNATIVE 20:07:55 FOR THAT SECTION OF OBLIGATION ONLY. THAT IS THE ONLY WAY WE WILL GET 20:07:58 THE BMR'S REQUIRED 20:08:02 BY 20:08:07 RHNA, INCREASING IN LIEU FEES WILL NOT 20:08:10 GET DEVELOPERS TO SELECT THE INCLUSIVE OPTION. 20:08:14 AT THE COUNCIL WORK SESSION COUNCILMEMBER KENG REMARKED THAT 20:08:17 IT IS MORE COSTLY AND HARDER TO GET SOMEONE OUT OF HOME 20:08:20 LESSNESS THAN TO PREVENT THEIR HOMELESSNESS IN THE 20:08:23 FIRST PLACE. 20:08:26 LAST WORK 20:08:29 SESSION PRESENTATION SHOWED THAT AFFORDABLE 20:08:33 INCLUSIONARY UNITS ARE PRODUCED MORE QUICKLY THAN 20:08:36 THOSE FINANCED WITH IN-LIEU FEES. PLEASE REMOVE 20:08:39 THE IN-LIEU ALTERNATIVE FOR THE FOR SALE MODERATE 20:08:43 OR LOW INCOME IMPACT OBLIGATIONS, UNDER 20:08:47 18155080 20:08:50 A. PLANNING COMMISSIONER MCDONALD BROUGHT UP 20:08:53 ANOTHER POINT. CURRENTLY, THE IN LIEU 20:08:56 FEES COLLECTED FOR THE MODERATE OR LOW 20:09:00 INCOME IMPACT OBLIGATIONS ARE NOT BEING USED 20:09:03 FOR THOSE ARE MODERATE INCOME. FREMONT 20:09:06 DOESN'T HELP ITS TEACHERS, HEALTH CARE WORKERS OR 20:09:09 SERVICE PROVIDERS, MAKING BETWEEN 89 20:09:13 ,000 AND $120,000, 20:09:15 AFFORD TO LIVE IN FREMONT. THANK YOU. 20:09:18 AND NOW I HAVE CHRIS. IF YOU COULD RESET THE TIMER 20:09:21 . IS 20:09:27 . >> GOOD EVENING, THIS IS CHRIS CAIIVET. 20:09:30 CAIVETD. YOU ARE 20:09:33 BEING ASKED TO MAKE A DECISION THAT WILL EFFECT SOME OF THE 20:09:36 LAST BUILTABLE LAND IN FREMONT . I THINK THIS IS 20:09:39 TIME TO SEND A CLEAR MESSAGE TO DEVELOPERS THAT ALL 20:09:42 FUTURE FOR-SALE RESIDENTIAL DWROMENTS MUST 20:09:46 DEVELOPMENTS MUST INCLUDE A SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT 20:09:49 OF ONSITE AFFORDABLE HOUSING TO MEET THE MODERATE AND 20:09:52 LOW INCOME IMPACT OBLIGATIONS WITH NO IN 20:09:55 -LIEU FEE ALTERNATIVE. 20:09:58 THAT INCLUDES CAN 20:10:02 SINGLE FAMILY MULTIFAMILY 20:10:05 MIXED USE TOWN CENTER AND ANY OTHER DEVELOPMENTS THAT 20:10:08 HAVE FOR SALE HOUSING UNITS. IF WE DO 20:10:11 NOT REQUIRE THE INCLUSION OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING FOR THE MODERATE AND LOW 20:10:14 LEVELS NOW, WE WILL NEVER GET IT. INCREASING 20:10:17 THE IN-LIEU FEES WILL NOT ACHIEVE 20:10:20 DID IS DESIRED RESULT. WE ARE RUNNING OUT OF 20:10:23 LAND AND WE ARE RUNNING OUT OF TIME. WE NEED 20:10:27 TO REQUIRE INCLUSIONARY HOUSING 20:10:30 NOW. THANK YOU. 20:10:35 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. AND NEXT SPEAKER IS DENNIS 20:10:38 MARTIN. FTC WELCOME. 20:10:42 WELCOME. 20:10:46 >> THANK YOU, MAYOR AND COUNCIL. DENNIS MARTIN SPEAKING ON 20:10:49 BEHALF OF BIA BAY AREA. AND 20:10:53 FIRST OF ALL I WANTED TO EXPRESS OUR 20:10:56 APPRECIATION TO STAFF AND THE CITY 20:10:59 FOR THEIR OUTREACH EFFORTS ON THIS ISSUE 20:11:02 . THEY'VE BEEN EXEMPLARY 20:11:07 AND WE WISH EVERY CITY WAS AN 20:11:11 CONSCIENTIOUS AS FREMONT IS ABOUT MAKING SURE THEY CHECK IN 20:11:14 WITH STAKEHOLDERS ON THESE IMPORTANT ISSUES. 20:11:17 BY AND LARGE BIA DOES CONCUR 20:11:20 WITH STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS. YOU'LL NEVER HEAR BI 20:11:24 A ENDORSE A FEE INCREASE OF THIS NATURE. 20:11:27 ESPECIALLY ON FOR-SALE HOMES BECAUSE FOR- 20:11:30 SALE HOMES ARE WHAT IS THE BACKBONE OF THE COMMUNITY 20:11:33 COMMUNITY. AND THAT WE HOPE THE CITY 20:11:36 COUNCIL UNDERSTANDS THAT PROVIDING HOME OWNERSHIP 20:11:40 IN THE COMMUNITY IS A VERY, VERY IMPORTANT 20:11:43 ISSUE. WE WOULD LIKE 20:11:46 TO DRAW THE CITY COUNCIL'S ATTENTION 20:11:49 TO THE LETTER THAT WE HAVE SUBMITTED ON TONIGHT'S 20:11:53 ITEM. AND ONE PARTICULAR ITEM WHICH 20:11:56 IS THE FEE THE DEFERRAL ISSUE. 20:11:59 TWO YEARS AGO, THE CITY COUNCIL DECIDED TO 20:12:03 O 20:12:06 TO ELIMINATE FEE DEFERRAL ON MARKET 20:12:09 RATE UNITS. AND THAT REPRESENTS A SUBSTANTIAL INCREASE IN 20:12:13 COSTS TO THE DEVELOPMENT OF RESIDENTIAL 20:12:15 UNITS. AND WE THINK THAT THE COUNCIL 20:12:18 NEEDS TO REVISIT THAT. AND WITH THIS 20:12:23 ORDINANCE UPDATE IT IS A PERFECT OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT 20:12:27 . YOU'VE ALREADY DECIDED TO PROVIDE 20:12:30 SOME EXEMPTIONS FOR AFFORDABLE UNITS. WE THINK YOU 20:12:33 SHOULD GO A LITTLE BIT FURTHERS AND REVISIT THAT POLICY AND 20:12:36 ALLOW MARKET RATE UNITS CAN TO PAY 20:12:39 TO PAY FEES AT 20:12:43 CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY. SO WE THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME 20:12:46 . AND GOOD NIGHT 20:12:49 . >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. 20:12:54 AND AT THIS TIME I WILL CLOSE THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD. 20:12:58 NO, WAIT, SA 20:13:02 LIM MESTAN. 20:13:09 >> HOLM, MAYOR, CAN YOU HEAR ME? HELLO 20:13:12 , HELLO. HELLO 20:13:15 . >> The Clerk: YES, WE CAN LAYER YOU, PLEASE PROCEED. 20:13:18 >> YES, HI, CONGRATULATIONS FOR TRYING TO DO SOMETHING 20:13:21 GOOD THAT IS NEEDED AND REQUIRED 20:13:25 . AND THE ISSUE 20:13:29 OF CAN WE WORK WITH THE HOMELESS PEOPLE 20:13:32 AND WE UNDERSTAND HOW A PERSON FROM HAVING A HOME TO 20:13:35 NO HOME TO BECOMING HOMELESS, IT'S A 20:13:38 SERIES OF STEPS THAT HAPPENS, THAT 20:13:42 MAKE PEOPLE EITHER HOMELESS OR MOVE 20:13:45 OUT OF THE STATE. 20:13:48 I HAVE ONE QUESTION VERY SIMPLE, THAT THERE ARE 20:13:51 MANY, MANY COMMUNITIES AND MANY CHURCHES WHO ARE WORKING 20:13:55 TO BUILD HOMES 20:13:58 FOR THEIR COMMUNITY. AND WE ARE ALSO WORKING 20:14:02 TO MAKE 20:14:05 A UNIT COMMUNITY BASED HOME. IS IT POSSIBLE THAT IF 20:14:09 WE WANT TO BUILD THE HOMES AND 20:14:12 AWARD THIS TO THE COMMUNITY, 20:14:15 OR THE COMMUNITIES THAT WE BELONG TO, THAT 20:14:18 WAY, WE WOULD NEED 20:14:21 LESS CITY FUNDING 20:14:25 ENROLLMENT FUNDING, FUND THE PROJECTS 20:14:28 AND AWARDED THROUGHOUT PEOPLE 20:14:32 WHO ARE 20:14:37 APPLYING FOR THESE BELOW-MARKET-RATE HOMES 20:14:40 . THAT IS A QUESTION THAT I HAVE. THANK YOU, BECKLENBERG. 20:14:45 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. AND WE'LL NOW CLOSE 20:14:48 THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD. 20:14:52 AND BRING IT BACK TO THE COUNCIL 20:14:55 FOR CONVERSATION AND DISCUSSION. COULD WE PLEASE BRING UP 20:14:58 THE RECOMMENDATIONS THIS EVENING FOR THE STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS? 20:15:05 THANK YOU. AND SO AT THIS TIME, I'LL TURN IT BACK TO 20:15:08 OUR COUNCIL FOR CONVERSATION AND DISCUSSIONS 20:15:12 . 20:15:16 VICE MAYOR SHAO. >> Councilmember Shao: THANK 20:15:20 YOU, MAYOR MEI. I'M GLAD THAT THE 20:15:23 STAFF, THROUGH THE NEXUS ANALYSIS 20:15:27 , DID FIND SOME DATA. I'M 20:15:30 JUST CONCERNED THAT WHILE WE'RE INCREASING THE FEE LEVEL 20:15:33 FOR FOR SALE PROJECTS, WE ARE REDUCING THE PERCENTAGE 20:15:38 FOR THE INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENT FOR 20:15:42 THE FOR SALE PROJECTS FROM OVER, YOU KNOW, YOU 20:15:45 21% ALL THE 20:15:48 21% TO 20:15:52 DOWN LIKE 15%. IT IS TYPICAL BARGAIN 20:15:55 ING STRATEGY, YOU WIN SOME, YOU LOSE SOME. 20:15:58 I WONDER WHETHER THAT WOULD HELP WITH THE CITY COUNCIL 20:16:03 CITY COUNCIL'S RESOLVE TO 20:16:06 ENCOURAGE DEVELOPERS TO BUILD MORE 20:16:09 AFFORDABLE HOUSING. 20:16:13 I WOULD LIKE TO KEEP 20:16:17 THE INCLUSIONARY 20:16:21 REQUIREMENT CLOSER TO THE ORIGINAL 20:16:24 PERCENTAGE, IF POSSIBLE 20:16:28 . IS THERE 20:16:31 ANY STRONG REASON FOR SUCH A REDUCTION 20:16:35 , STAFF PLEASE? 20:16:43 >> SO THE STATE SAYS THAT ANY INCLUSIONARY 20:16:46 REQUIREMENT OVER AND ABOVE 15% 20:16:50 MUST MEET STATE REVIEW. 20:16:54 BECAUSE STATE IS SAYING THAT 20:16:57 AT OR 15% OR LOWER GENERALLY IT DOES 20:17:00 NOT SUPPRESS THE DEVELOPMENT OF MARKET 20:17:04 RATE HOUSING. BUT HIGHER THAN 15 20:17:07 % GENERALLY WILL REQUIRE 20:17:11 A STATE REVIEW ON THIS ONE. SO THAT'S WHY WE WANT TO KEEP 20:17:14 IT AT 15%, THAT'S ONE REASON. AND ALSO, 20:17:18 OUR FEASIBILITY STUDY SHOWS THAT 20:17:22 THE -- IT'S FEASIBLE TO REQUIRE A 20:17:25 TEN TO 20%. AND SO THAT'S WHY 20:17:28 STAFF WANTS TO STAY AT THIS 15%. TO 20:17:32 SEE 20:17:35 HOW MUCH WE CAN GET HOUSING BUILT. AND ALSO WE TRY 20:17:39 THE 21% BEFORE, DURING THIS ORDINANCE, THE 18% 20:17:42 TO 21.6%. WE DID NOT GET 20:17:46 ANY INCLUSIONARY HOUSING USING THESE PERCENTAGES. BECAUSE 20:17:49 THE DEVELOPERS ARE SAYING THAT IT SUPPRESSES 20:17:52 THE PRODUCTION OF ONSITE UNITS. SO THAT'S WHY 20:17:56 STAFF LANDS ON 15%. AS 20:18:00 THE RECOMMENDATION. 20:18:02 >> Dan Schoenholz: AND IF I CAN JUST CLARIFY. 20:18:05 WE HAVE AN EXISTING 20:18:08 REQUIREMENT OF 18 TO 21.6% 20:18:12 . WE WOULDN'T ACTUALLY NEED -- THE STATE WOULDN'T 20:18:15 HAVE ANY ABILITY TO REVIEW THAT. BECAUSE IT'S ALREADY 20:18:18 IN OUR ORDINANCE ARE. SO IF COUNCIL WANTED TO 20:18:24 . SO IF COUNCIL WANTED TO KEEP THE 18 TO 21 20:18:27 .6% INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENTS THAT ARE 20:18:31 THERE YOU COULD, AND IT WOULDN'T SUBJECT US TO 20:18:34 STATE REVIEW. AS MENTION ID, THE STATE 20:18:38 IS SIGNALING THAT 15% IS IF LEVEL THAT 20:18:42 IS KIND OF STANDARD AND ANYTHING ABOVE THAT IS SOMETHING THEY WANT TO 20:18:45 LOOK AT. BUT BECAUSE WE ALREADY HAVE IT IN OUR ORDINANCE 20:18:48 WE WOULDN'T BE SUBJECT TO STATE 20:18:51 REVIEW. AND 20:18:54 , YOU KNOW, SO OIT IS AN OPTION. BUT AS ALUCIA 20:18:58 AS LUCE QULA 20:19:05 LUCIA SEDATE 20:19:09 ED, 21% IS RECOMMENDED AS 20:19:12 FEASIBLE AND WE'RE RECOMMENDING 10% 20:19:15 LOW INCOME AND NATURALLY IF YOU HAVE SOME LOW INCOME UNITS 20:19:18 MIXED IN THERE, IT'S LESS FEASIBLE 20:19:21 BECAUSE THE DEVELOPER HAS TO SUBSIDIZE 20:19:24 THE UNITS MORE. SO WE DIDN'T SPECIFICALLY HAVE 20:19:28 THE CONSULTANT STUDY WHAT A MIX 20:19:31 OF MODERATE AND LOW WOULD BE FEASIBLE 20:19:34 . BUT IT WOULD BE SOMETHING LESS THAN 20% 20:19:39 . 20:19:44 >> Councilmember Shao: OKAY SO IF LET'S JUST SAY KEEP IT 20 20:19:47 % OVERALL WITH 10% MODERATE, 10 20:19:50 % LOW, THAT WOULD STILL FALL INTO THE BRACKET 20:19:53 THAT THE STATE WOULD ORECOMMEND 20:19:56 , OR ALLOW, AND ALSO, THE 20:19:59 FEERVEL STUDY WOULDss 20:20:06 FEASIBILITY STUDY WOULD 20:20:09 RECOMMEND, IS THAT CORRECT? >> Dan Schoenholz: THAT'S 20:20:13 CORRECT. >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU NEXT 20:20:16 CLARIFYING QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS. 20:20:19 COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN. >> Councilmember Salwan: THANK YOU MAYOR AND THANK YOU 20:20:22 STAFF FOR THIS PRESENTATION. I WAS KIND OF SURPRISED ORIGINAL 20:20:25 ORIGINALLY BECAUSE I WOULD THINK THAT MORE COUNCILMEMBERS WOULD 20:20:28 WANT TO HAVE MORE PROJECTS BUILT ONSITE AS 20:20:31 INCLUSIONARY HOUSING. BUT WHEN WITH EVOTED LAST TIME MOST WANTED 20:20:35 THE IN LIEU FEES SO THAT WE COULD GET MORE SUBSIDY 20:20:38 AND HAVE LARGER PROJECTS. SO THAT WE 20:20:41 COULD HELP MORE FOLKS WITH EXTREMELY LOW AND 20:20:44 VERY LOW INCOME. ONE OF THE AREAS THAT WE ARE 20:20:47 STILL STRUGGLING WITH IS THE MIDDLE HOUSING. 20:20:50 AND I STILL THINK WE HAVE ZERO, RIGHT? 20:20:53 WE NEVER HIT THOSE GOALS. HOW DO WE INCENTIVIZE 20:20:56 THOSE IN SOME OF THESE FEES 20:20:59 ? >> Dan Schoenholz: RIGHT 20:21:03 . YOU KNOW WHETHER YOU SAY MIDDLE, COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN, 20:21:06 ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT MODERATE INCOME 20:21:09 ? >> Councilmember Salwan: MODERATE INCOME. 20:21:12 YES. >> Dan Schoenholz: ZOO MODERATE 20:21:15 INCOME HOUSING IS A DIFFICULTY SEGMENT FOR US 20:21:18 TO GET BUILT. YOU KNOW THE SPEAKERS TALKED 20:21:21 SPEAKERS TALKED ABOUT MANDATE 20:21:24 ING MODERATE INCOME INCLUSIONARY UNITS AND THAT 20:21:27 WOULD BE ONE WAY TO GET THEM BUILT. 20:21:30 BUT OBVIOUSLY THE TRADEOFF WOULD BE THAT THE FEES COLLECT 20:21:34 ED WOULD BE MUCH LOWER. SO IT'S REALLY KIND OF A IT'S A 20:21:37 TRADEOFF, WHERE DO YOU WANT THE RESOURCES THAT ARE COMING FROM MARKET RATE 20:21:40 DEVELOPMENT TO BE TARGETED? NOR MODERATE 20:21:44 FOR MODERATE INCOME HOUSING 20:21:48 ONE OF THE CHALLENGES IS THAT YOU DON'T GET STATE AND 20:21:51 FEDERAL CONTRIBUTIONS. YOU DON'T LEVERAGE IN ANY 20:21:54 OUTSIDE DOLLARS, IN THE WAY THAT YOU DO WHEN YOU COLLECT 20:21:58 FEES, AND THEN YOU USE THOSE TO 20:22:02 CONSTRUCT AFFORDABLE MULTIFAMILY 20:22:05 RENTAL PROJECTS. AND SO THERE IS AN ADVANTAGE 20:22:08 , AND I THINK THAT'S ONE OF THE REASONS THAT THE COUNCIL WAS 20:22:11 VERY INTERESTED IN CONTINUING TO COLLECT IN LIEU FEES. 20:22:14 YOU CAN USE THOSE IN LIEU FEES 20:22:18 TO ATTRACT OUTSIDE FUNDING TO KIND OF EXPAND THE PIE 20:22:21 THAT'S USED FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING. 20:22:26 SO THOSE ARE SOME OF THE TRADEOFFS, OBVIOUSLY 20:22:29 WE WOULD LOVE TO BE ABLE TO DO A LOT OF BOTH BUT 20:22:33 IT IS REALLY KIND OF A ZERO SUM GAME. THERE IS ONLY 20:22:36 SO MUCH SUBSIDY AVAILABLE. 20:22:37 >> Councilmember Salwan: THANKS FOR EXPANDING ON THE 20:22:41 LEVERAGING ASPECT OF IT. REGARDING VICE MAYOR SHAO 20:22:44 'S CONCERN ABOUT THE INCLUSIONARY 20:22:47 , THE PERCENTAGES. SO ARE WE GET 20:22:50 TING ANY PROJECTS BUILT AT THE CURRENT STATE, DO YOU 20:22:53 THINK IF WE WERE LOWER WE WOULD GET MORE BUILT, 20:22:56 OR WHAT'S THE STATUS? >> Dan Schoenholz: YES, 20:23:00 I MEAN AS I MENTIONED WE HAVEN'T HAD A 20:23:03 SINGLE PROJECT BUILT IN THE LAST SIX YEARS WHERE 20:23:07 A DEVELOPER PROVIDED, YOU KNOW, EITHER THE 18% 20:23:10 OR THE 21.6 20:23:13 % UNITS 20:23:16 , INCLUSIONARY UNITS. BUT YOU KNOW THAT MAY BE OKAY IF 20:23:19 WHAT YOU REALLY WANT TO DO IS DRIVER THE DEVELOPER 20:23:23 TOWARDS PAYING IN-LIEU FEES, THEN 20:23:26 KEEPING IT ATE A HIGH LEVEL IS ONE WAY TO DO 20:23:29 THAT. I THINK WE -- ALTHOUGH IT WASN'T 20:23:32 CLEAR FROM THE COUNCIL WORK SESSION, I THINK WE DID -- 20:23:36 WE THOUGHT WE HEARD AN INTEREST IN TRYING 20:23:39 TO INCENTIVIZE A 20:23:42 BIT OF MODERATE INCOME INCLUSIONARY 20:23:45 HOUSING WITHOUT REQUIRING IT, SEEING IF WE 20:23:49 COULD TWEAK THE ORDINANCE 20:23:52 IN THE WAY THERE WAS SOME PRODUCTION. 20:23:55 THAT IS ONE OF OUR REASONING FOR REQUIRING THE 15% REQUIREMENT. 20:24:00 THE OTHER WAS FRANKLY TO BE SORT OF A 20:24:06 ALIGNED WITH OTHER DISAND MAKE IT SORT OF SIMPLER. 20:24:09 OUR ORDINANCE LAST TIME AROUND WAS KIND OF 20:24:12 COMPLEX AND THAT WAS BECAUSE OF THE LEGAL ENVIRONMENT THAT EXIST 20:24:16 ED AT THE TIME. SO WE WERE THINKING THAT WE COULD ACCOMPLISH SEVERAL 20:24:19 HE OBJECTIVES AT ONCE BY CHANGING 20:24:22 THE INCLUSIONARY REQUIREMENT. BUT CERTAINLY THE COUNCIL COULD 20:24:25 LEAVE IT WHERE IT IS AND THAT WOULD TEND 20:24:29 TO, I THINK, RESULT IN DEVELOPERS 20:24:33 ALMOST UNANIMOUSLY EITHER PAYING THE ENTIRE 20:24:36 FEE OR POTENTIALLY DOING THAT HYBRID OPTION. 20:24:39 THAT'S THE OTHER PIECE. IS THEY COULD CHOOSE TO 20:24:43 BUILD THEIR MODERATE INCOME REQUIREMENT AND THEN PAY A 20:24:46 PARTIAL FEE. 20:24:47 SO -- >> Councilmember Salwan: 20:24:50 THAT'S AN INTERESTING POINT YOU JUST MADE THERE, THAT IF WE WERE 20:24:54 TO INCREASE THE 20:24:58 INCLUSIONARY NEARNLG WOULD IN FACT DRIVE THEM TO PAY IN- 20:25:01 LIEU FEES SO YOU WOULDN'T GET 20:25:04 VERY MUCH INCLUSIONARY HOUSING AT ALL. THAT'S 20:25:07 THE INCENTIVES AND THE DISINCENTIVES, GOOD DISCUSSION. REGARDING THE 20:25:10 REST OF THE ITEMS, I THINK I'M OKAY WITH WHAT STAFF IS 20:25:13 PROPOSING. I THINK 44 IS FINE. I THINK THAT'S PRETTY HIGH 20:25:16 . WE ALWAYS GET CRITICIZE THEY'D WE HAVE DID 20:25:19 HIGHEST FEES. I THINK IF 44 IS AMONG THE 20:25:22 HIGHEST I THINK WE'RE GOOD. WE DON'T NEED TO -- 20:25:25 I DON'T SEE ANY REASON TO GO ABOVE THAT IF WE ARE ALREADY 20:25:29 AT THE MAXIMUM FEES. BECAUSE A LOT 20:25:32 OF FEES ADD TO THE COST OF HOUSING WHICH CAUSES 20:25:35 MORE EXPENSIVE HOUSING FOR THE REST OF THE FOLKS. 20:25:38 SO I'M OKAY WITH STAFF RECOMMENDATION. I'M OPEN TO 20:25:42 FEEDBACK FROM VICE MAYOR SHAO AND OUR COLLEAGUES ABOUT 20:25:45 THE PERCENTAGE FOR 20:25:47 INCLUSIONARY PERCENTAGES. THANK YOU. 20:25:50 >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU. 20:25:54 COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN. >> Councilmember Kassan: YES 20:25:57 , IT IS THE DEFINITELY A CONUNDRUM. 20:26:00 BECAUSE IF WE, YOU KNOW, IF WE REQUIRE TOO HIGH 20:26:03 OF INCLUSIONARY, THEN IT BASICALLY MEANS WE DON'T GET ANY 20:26:07 . SO THAT IT IS TOUGH. AND I FEEL LIKE THE NUMBERS 20:26:10 THAT THE STAFF CAME UP WITH, 20:26:12 IT IS DISAPPOINTING TO SEE THEM GOING DOWN. 20:26:15 BUT I DO THINK THAT, YOU KNOW, IRONICALLY IT WILL 20:26:18 PROBABLY LEAD TO MORE OF IT HAPPENING. I DO 20:26:22 SUPPORT INCREASING THE PER SQUARE FOOT 20:26:25 FEE FOR TOWN HOMES TO $50. THE 20:26:28 NEXUS STUDY DID SAY THAT THE MARKET SUPPORTS 20:26:32 THAT. AND I 20:26:35 THINK, YOU KNOW, IT'S A TRADEOFF, 20:26:38 OBVIOUSLY, YES IT IS GOING TO INCREASE THE COST 20:26:41 FOR DEVELOPERS BUT IT ALSO WILL INCREASE THE POT OF MONEY 20:26:43 AVAILABLE TO DEVELOP OAFFORDABLE HOUSING. 20:26:46 SO I WOULD VERY MUCH SUPPORT MAKING 20:26:50 THAT AN ALTERNATIVE RESOLUTION TO MAKE THAT CHANGE 20:26:55 . >> Mayor Mei: THANK YOU, COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN. 20:26:58 NEXT IS COUNCILMEMBER COX. 20:27:03 >> Councilmember Cox: MY APOLOGIES 20:27:06 YOU'RE ON MUTE. >> Councilmember Cox: IF WE INCREASE THE 20:27:10 FEE LEVEL FOR FOR-SALE PROJECTS TO 20:27:13 $44, IS FOR SQUARE FOOT 20:27:16 , WHERE IS THAT RANKED 20:27:20 ? YOU KNOW, ARE WE IN THE MIDDLE 20:27:23 , ARE WE NEAR THE BOTTOM OF THE 20:27:25 TOP? I JUST WANT TO KIND OF 20:27:29 UNDERSTAND WHERE ARE WE PLACED IN THE MARKET IF WE GO TO THAT 20:27:31 RATE? >> Dan Schoenholz: THAT WOULD 20:27:36 PUT US, THE $44 IS HIGHER THAN ANY 20:27:39 OF THE SURROUNDING CITIES THAT WE LOOKED AT. SAN JOSE DOES HAVE 20:27:42 A $43 FEE 20:27:46 FOR, I THINK THE IT'S 20:27:49 A SPECIFIC GEOGRAPHIC AREA. IT 20:27:53 DOESN'T COVER DID ENTIRE COMMUNITY BUT THEY HAVE ONE SCENARIO 20:27:57 WHERE THE FEE IS $AG 20:28:00 $43. SO IT WOULD BE CLOSE TO THAT. BUT OTHER THAN THAT 20:28:03 WE DIDN'T SEE ANYTHING IN THE 40s. 20:28:06 I THINK THE LOW 30s, HIGH 20s 20:28:09 WE SAW IN SOME OTHER COMMUNITIES 20:28:12 . >> Councilmember Cox: SO WHAT WOULD BE NEARBY 20:28:15 FOR NEWARK AND UNION CITY, WHAT WOULD BE THEIR RATES? 20:28:19 I'M JUST CURIOUS, YOU TO HAYWARD AND JUST KIND 20:28:22 OF SEEING WHERE ARE WE ON THE EAST BAY 20:28:26 ? >> SO THIS IS DAVID D 20:28:29 OZEMA WITH 20:28:32 KEYSER-MARSTON. UNION CITY IS ABOUT $27 20:28:35 PER SQUARE FOOT. NEWARK I DON'T HAVE 20:28:39 HANDY BUT HAYWARD IS AT $19 PER SQUARE FOOT. 20:28:42 WE LOOKED AT LIVERMORE, THEY'RE AT 20:28:45 $28 PER SQUARE FOOT. >> Councilmember Cox: WHAT 20:28:48 ABOUT MEN TON 20:28:52 PLEASANTON 20:28:56 ? >> I DON'T HAVE THAT HANDY. MILPITAS THEY'RE 20:29:00 AT 33. SAN JOSE AS MR. SCHOENHOLZ 20:29:03 MENTIONED IS AT $43 PER RENTALS AND 20:29:06 THEY HAVE $25 FOR FOR-SALE. 20:29:10 >> Councilmember Cox: THAT STILL PUTS US UP THERE PRETTY HIGH 20:29:13 . >> YES. SO I THINK, I 20:29:17 THINK THE BROAD PICTURE IS THAT THAT FOR-SALE FEE 20:29:21 IS TOWARDS THE HIGH END. AND 20:29:24 THE RENTAL IS TOWARDS THE LOW END. AND THE 20:29:27 STACKED-FLAT-CONDO RECOMMENDATIONS ARE 20:29:30 RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE IS SORT OF HOW I WOULD PUT IT. 20:29:35 >> Councilmember Cox: RIGHT BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT YOU'RE 20:29:38 NOT TOUCHING IS THE STACKED, THE OTHER ONES, THE TOWN 20:29:41 HOUSE, ARE WE BUILDING, DO WE HAVE A TENDENCY 20:29:44 TO BUILD MORE TOWN HOUSES NOW IT LOOKS LIKE 20:29:47 THAN SINGLE FAMILY HOMES? WOOU SAY THAT'S A 20:29:50 FAIR ASSESSMENT GOING IN THE FUTURE? >> I WOULD. 20:29:55 >> Councilmember Cox: HOW LIKELY, ARE YOU THINKING IT'S TWO TO 20:29:58 ONE NOW? >> Dan Schoenholz: YEAH, 20:30:01 I MEAN I THINK 20:30:04 -- WE'RE SEEING HIGHER DENSITY 20:30:08 DEVELOPMENT SO I THINK YOU SEE MORE TOWN HOMES THAN SINGLE 20:30:11 FAMILY HOMES AND MAY SEE MORE STACKED FLATS 20:30:14 THAN TOWN HOMES IN THE FUTURE. 20:30:17 >> Councilmember Cox: OKAY. I JUST THINK THAT 44 IS STILL 20:30:20 QUITE HIGH WHEN OTHERS ARE MUCH 20:30:23 LESS. I DON'T KNOW WHERE THEY ARE IN 20:30:27 TERMS OF THEIR REASSESSMENT 20:30:30 OF LOOKING FORWARD. BUT WHEN EVERYBODY 20:30:33 ELSE 20:30:37 IS 27, 28, 23, 19, 25 20:30:41 , 44 IS PRETTY STEEP COMPARED TO THE REST OF THE SURROUND 20:30:44 ING AREAS THERE. AND MAYBE LOOKING 20:30:47 AT, YOU KNOW, $39 OR SOMETHING 20:30:51 , 40, AROUND THERE. 20:30:54 AND IN TERMS OF THE 20:30:58 -- HAVING THE FEE INCREASE INTO 20:31:01 TWO STEPS, WHY TWO STEPS, VERSUS LOOKING 20:31:04 AT IT GOING INTO THREE, DOING 20:31:07 A THREE-STEP? BECAUSE IT LOOKS LIKE $ 20:31:10 8 ONE INCREASE ONE YEAR AND THEN HITTING 20:31:13 UP ANOTHER EIGHT OR 9 THE FOLLOWING YEAR AS OPPOSED 20:31:17 TO KIND OF SMOOTHING IS IT OUT A LITTLE BIT MORE 20:31:20 . >> Dan Schoenholz: RIGHT, YEAH, WE RECOMMENDED 20:31:23 THE TWO STEPS. IT WAS REALLY KIND OF 20:31:26 BASED ON COUNCIL INTEREST AND DIRECTION AROUND TRYING TO INCREASE 20:31:28 HAD RESOURCES FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING. 20:31:31 SO IT WAS SORT OF TRYING TO BALANCE GETTING 20:31:34 MORE MONEY SOONER, WITH RECOGNIZE 20:31:37 ING THAT MARKET 20:31:41 RATE PROJECTS NEED SOME TIME TO ADJUST TO THE MARKETPLACE 20:31:44 . SO WE CERTAINLY COULD DO 20:31:47 THREE STEPS, IF THAT WAS COUNCIL'S WISH 20:31:51 . AND I THINK WE EVEN HAVE A 20:31:54 SLIDE THAT SHOWS WHAT THAT WOULD LOOK LIKE IF WE DID IT IN THREE 20:31:57 STEPS. BUT TWO STEPS IS WHAT WE THOUGHT 20:32:00 WAS KIND OF MORE IN LINE WITH COUNCIL DIRECTION. >> Councilmember Cox: 20:32:04 CAN YOU SHOW US WHAT YOU HAD FOR YOUR PROPOSAL FOR A THREE 20:32:07 -STEP PLEASE? >> YES, ALBERTO, 20:32:10 PLEASE GO TO SLIDE NUMBER 26. >> Mayor Mei: I JUST WANTED 20:32:13 TO NOTE ALSO WE'LL DAY ONE CLARIFYING QUESTION BUT 20:32:17 IT'S GOING TO GO LONGER WE 20:32:21 SHOULD PROBABLY DAY A BREAK TOO. AFTER 20:32:24 COUNCILMEMBER KENG ASK SS QUESTIONS WE MIGHT HAVE TO COME BACK TO MAKE 20:32:28 OUR FINAL YOU DECISIONS. >> HERE IS THE SLIDE 20:32:31 THAT SHOWS THREE STEPS INSTEAD OF TWO STEPS 20:32:33 STEPS. SO THE FULL FEE WILL NOT COME 20:32:36 INTO EFFECT UNTIL 2024. THE $44 20:32:40 . CRZ I THINK THAT WOULD BE MORE REASONABLE. 20:32:44 REASONABLE BECAUSE 20:32:47 EVERYBODY'S JUST COMING THROUGH GETTING BACK ON TRACK 20:32:50 AND BOUNCING BACK FROM THE PANDEMIC 20:32:55 . AND WE KIND OF THE NEED TO 20:32:58 SMOOTH IT OUT A LITTLE BIT AND SOME CONSIDERATION THERE 20:33:01 BUT NOT AT THE COST OF REDUCING 20:33:05 AFFORDABLE HOUSING. 20:33:08 THE VERY LOW INCOME. THIS IS GOOD TO KNOW 20:33:13 . >> Mayor Mei: COUNCILMEMBER KENG CLARIFYING QUESTIONS 20:33:16 AND THEN I SAID AFTERWARDS I THINK 20:33:19 WE MIGHT TAKE A QUICK BREAK BEFORE WE COME BACK DO MAKE 20:33:23 OUR FINAL COMMENTS. 20:33:25 >> Councilmember Keng: I ACTUALLY DON'T HAVE QUESTIONS AT 20:33:28 THIS TIME, I HAVE COMMENTS. >> Mayor Mei: GO AHEAD AND MAKE YOUR COMMENTS 20:33:31 . >> Councilmember Keng: SURE, YES. 20:33:34 I DON'T THINK THAT -- YOU KNOW, I AM OKAY WITH THE $ 20:33:38 44 BUT I ALSO PEOPLE THAT WE SHOULD MAKE IT A THREE 20:33:41 -STEP INSTEAD OF TWO. AND 20:33:45 I DON'T THINK I'LL BE SUPPORTIVE FOR GOING HIGHER THAN THAT. 20:33:48 I THINK IT'S ALREADY PRETTY HIGH CONSIDERING THE BUILDING COSTS 20:33:51 HAVE GONE UP TREMENDOUSLY DURING THE LAST 20:33:54 YEAR AND A HALF DURING PANDEMIC. 20:33:58 AND I 20:34:03 -- YEAH I THINK WE DO WANT TO HAVE 20:34:06 MORE FUNDING FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING 20:34:10 SO THE SLIDE -- >> Mayor Mei: COUNCILMEMBER 20:34:13 KENG, SORRY. >> Councilmember Keng: HELLO, YES 20:34:17 , I DO FEEL THAT FOR THE REST 20:34:21 OF THE PROPOSAL, I AM 20:34:24 AGREEABLE WITH. BUT I DON'T KNOW IF ANYONE ELSE 20:34:28 ALSO FEELS LIKE, YOU KNOW, 20:34:36 , YOU KNOW, WE SHOULD GIVE MORE TIME INSTEAD OF, WE USED 20:34:39 TO HAVE THEM PAY THE FEES, ALLOW THEM TO 20:34:42 PAY THE FEES IN STAGES. 20:34:46 AND WOULD THAT STILL BE A CONSIDERATION OR 20:34:49 NOT? 20:34:51 20:34:51 20:34:55 . >> Mayor Mei: SO DOES ANYONE ON STAFF WANT TO CLARIFY? 20:34:58 I SEE WE HAD A SPEAKER AN THIS EARLIER, I SEE COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN 20:35:01 . I WANTED TO COMMENT THAT WE USED TO HAVE AN 20:35:04 INCENTIVE, I GUESS IN TERMS OF HOW WE HAD MARKET RATE 20:35:07 HOUSING. AND THAT'S THE QUESTION THAT WAS -- 20:35:10 BUT WE HAVE NOT HAD A SHORTAGES OF MARKET RATE 20:35:13 HOUSING BEING BUILT. WE'VE HAD MORE OF 20:35:17 A CHALLENGE IN TERMS OF LOW INCOME. AND IN PARTICULAR, AS 20:35:20 I THINK 20:35:22 COUNCILMEMBER -- I DON'T REMEMBER WHICH COUNCILMEMBER 20:35:25 MENTIONED IT BUT IN PARTICULAR WE HAVE MORE CHALLENGES IN MODERATE 20:35:29 HOUSING. I THINK IT WAS COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN THAT HAD MENTIONED 20:35:32 THAT AT THAT TIME, BECAUSE SOME OF THE PROGRAMS THAT HAVE BEEN PUT 20:35:36 IN PLACE SPECIFICALLY HAVE TARGETED LOW AND VERY LOW INCOME HOUSING 20:35:40 . SO I'M JUST WONDERING IF WE ARE 20:35:43 MOSTLY ALIGNED WITH THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION? 20:35:46 I TOO JUST WANTED TO COMMENT IN GENERAL THAT I 20:35:51 WOULD MAXIMUM FOR THE DISCUSSION OF THE PRICE INCREASE, 20:35:54 OR THE FEE INCREASE, GO UP TO 44. I WOULD NOT 20:35:57 BE INTERESTED IN GOING IN EXCESS TO $BRING 20:36:01 $50. I DO THINK 44 WOULD PUT US 20:36:04 AT THE HIGH END AND I DO LIKE THE 20:36:08 THREE TIER APPROACH VERSUS THE TWO TIER 20:36:11 . COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN. >> Councilmember Salwan: MADAM 20:36:14 MAYOR I THINK IN THE INTEREST OF DIME WE HAVE THE BUILDING 20:36:17 BLOCKS FOR A MOTION. >> Mayor Mei: DO YOU WANT 20:36:18 TO DO THAT? >> Councilmember Salwan: 20:36:22 ABSOLUTELY. THE ONLY THING FOR THE CLARIFICATION IS THE TWO-STEP 20:36:25 VERSUS THE THREE-STEP. ISN'T IT STILL THE 44 20:36:28 IN THE TWO-STEP, I WASN'T SURE WHAT THE DIFFERENCE WAS 20:36:31 . DO YOU HAVE A TWO-STEP SLIDE 20:36:35 ? >> Mayor Mei: I THINK IT WAS A DIFFERENCE OF DATES. 20:36:37 >> Councilmember Salwan: WAS IT DATES? 20:36:40 >> Dan Schoenholz: IT WAS THE DATES. IT WOULDN'T GO TO THE FULL $ 20:36:43 44 AMOUNT UNTIL HAD THE 20:36:48 2024, RIGHT, LUCIA? YOU WANT TO SHOW THE SLIDE 20:36:51 AGAIN. >> YES, ALBERTO CAN YOU 20:36:54 SHOW THAT SLIDE AGAIN? th 20:37:01 >> Councilmember Salwan: HOW DOES THAT DIFFER FROM THE TWO STEP THE DATES 20:37:04 ? >> THE TWO STEP WILL GO INTO EFFECT 20 20:37:08 23. THIS ONE THREE STEPS WILL GO INTO 20:37:11 EFFECT JANUARY 2024. AND ALBERTO IF YOU 20:37:14 CAN GO WAY UP TO SLIDE NUMBER 20 TO 20:37:17 SLIDE I WOULD SAY, LET'S SEE, AND TO 20:37:20 SHOW THE COUNCIL THE TWO- 20:37:24 STEP. YES, SO IF YOU CAN JUST 20:37:27 GO TO SLIDE I THINK 20:37:30 NUMBER 20:37:35 -- NUMBER 9 OR NUMBER 8. YES, NUMBER 20:37:39 8. SO WE'RE GOING TO SHOW YOU THE TWO STEPS 20:37:43 . NUMBER 8. YES 20:37:46 . YES. RIGHT HERE 20:37:50 . THESE TWO STEPS WILL SHOW YOU THAT THE FULL 20:37:53 FEE WILL GO INTO EFFECT JANUARY 2023. 20:37:56 >> Councilmember Salwan: OKAY SO I WOULD LIKE TO MOVE STAFF 20:37:59 RECOMMENDATION WITH THE THREE-STEP FORMULA WITH THE 20:38:02 20:38:06 MAX OF $ 20:38:10 44 FOR 20:38:13 STACKED FLATS AND SINGLE FAMILY. AS STAFF RECOMMENDED 20:38:16 . >> SECOND. >> Mayor Mei: COMENS DID YOU 20:38:20 HAVE 20:38:23 ANOTHER COMMENT? >> Councilmember Kassan: YES, I 20:38:26 UNDERSTAND THIS IS THE WAY THAT STAFF WANTS TO GO. 20:38:30 THIS IS AN AMAZING EFFECT, 20:38:33 WE DON'T DO THIS VERY OFTEN AT ALL AND 20:38:36 WE HAVE A HORRIBLE HOUSING CRISIS THROUGHOUT THE COUNTRY. 20:38:39 I JUST WONDER IF WE MIGHT WANT TO CONSIDER GOING TO 20:38:43 THE $50 PER SQUARE FOOT FOR TOWN 20:38:46 HOMES GIVEN IT WAS SHOWN AS FEASIBLE BY CONSULTANTS 20:38:49 THAT WE PAY A LOT OF MONEY TO TELL US WHAT WAS 20:38:52 FEASIBLE AND ALSO JUST DO THE TWO STEPS. 20:38:55 I WOULD VERY MUCH 74th THAT AND I WOULDN'T BE ABLE 20:38:58 TO VOTE IN FAVOR OF WHAT'S BEING PROPOSED. 20:39:02 IF I'M THE ONLY ONE OBVIOUSLY THAT IS THE WAY THE COOKIE 20:39:05 CRUMBLES. >> Mayor Mei: WE HAVE A MOTION. 20:39:07 COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN DID YOU HAVE A -- >> Councilmember Shao: I WOULD 20:39:10 LIKE TO SECOND 20:39:14 COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN'S PROPOSAL TO 20:39:17 INCREASE THE FEE FOR 20:39:20 THE TOWN HOUSES TO $50 PER SQUARE FEET 20:39:23 . >> Mayor Mei: OKAY 20:39:27 . WELL, WE HAVE A -- 20:39:30 I'M GOING TO TURN IT TO -- >> Councilmember Salwan: 20:39:33 JUST FOR UNDERSTANDING -- 20:39:36 >> Mayor Mei: WE HAVE A MOTION AND SECOND CLARIFYING 20:39:39 DEBRA DO WE VOTE ON THE FIRST ONE? THIS IS A 20:39:43 SECOND, A FRIENDLY AMENDMENT, IT'S NOT BEING 20:39:46 PUT THROUGH -- >> Ms. Margolis: THAT'S WHAT 20:39:49 I WANTED TO CLARIFY. COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN, ARE YOU 20:39:53 MAKING AN ALTERNATIVE HE MOTION? >> Councilmember Kassan: YES. >> Ms. Margolis: 20:39:56 WE HAVE AN ALTERNATIVE MOTION WITH A SECOND, 20:39:59 YOU NEED TO VOTE ON THAT ALTERNATIVE FIRST. >> Mayor Mei: 20:40:02 THAT'S WHAT I WANTED TO CLARIFY. >> Councilmember Salwan: JUST 20:40:05 TO DISTINGUISH YOU'RE DISTINGUISHING THE FEE FOR TOWN HOMES VERSUS 20:40:09 SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENCE. I'M TRYING 20:40:12 TO UNDERSTAND THE LOGIC ONE VERSUS DID OTHER? >> Councilmember Kassan: 20:40:15 BECAUSE THE NEXUS OR FEASIBILITY STUDY 20:40:18 SHOWS THAT $50 IS FEASIBLE FOR TOWN 20:40:22 HOMES BUT ONLY $44 IS FEASIBLE 20:40:25 FOR SINGLE FAMILY. JUST TO FOLLOW 20:40:28 DID DIRECTION OUR 20:40:30 CONSULTANTS PREPARED. >> Councilmember Salwan: IS 20:40:33 THAT CORRECT LUCIA OR BEN? >> YES, THAT'S CORRECT. 20:40:36 >> Councilmember Cox: WHEN WAS THE STUDY DONE? 20:40:39 >> IT WAS DONE A LITTLE BIT BEFORE OCTOBER 20 20:40:42 20. >> Councilmember Cox: YEAH 20:40:45 , THE PRICE OF LUMBER AND STEEL HAVE SKYROCKETED 20:40:48 . >> Mayor Mei: I ALSO WANTED JUST 20:40:51 TO CLARIFY THAT REGARDLESS, THIS WOULD PUT US OUTSIDE 20:40:54 THE NORM. DAVID IF THAT'S CORRECT, I THINK 20:40:58 THAT $50 WOULD BE AT THE HEIGHT FOR ANY OF 20:41:01 OUR SURROUNDING CITIES, CORRECT, THAT SURROUND US 20:41:04 ? >> THAT'S CORRECT. >> Mayor Mei: OKAY 20:41:07 . COUNCILMEMBER JONES. YOUR HAND RAISED 20:41:10 . >> Councilmember Jones: YOU JUST ASKED MY QUESTION, 20:41:13 ACTUALLY. >> Mayor Mei: OKAY, IN THAT CASE, ROLL CALL VOTE 20:41:16 PLEASE. >> Councilmember Cox: SO WAIT A MINUTE. 20:41:19 LET'S JUST CLARIFY WHAT ARE WE VOTING ON AGAIN 20:41:23 ? >> Mayor Mei: THIS IS THE ALTERNATIVE 20:41:25 . >> Ms. Margolis: ON THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION -- 20:41:28 >> Councilmember Cox: FOR $50. >> Ms. Margolis: INCREASING THE 20:41:31 FEE ON TOWN HOMES FOR $50. >> Mayor Mei: AND 20:41:34 TWO TIER VERSUS -- TWO- 20:41:37 STEP VERSUS A THREE-STEP. 20:41:41 >> Ms. Margolis: BUT OTHERWISE YOU WOULD BE FOLLOWING 20:41:44 STAFF RECOMMENDATION FOR EVERYTHING ELSE 20:41:47 . >> YES. >> Mayor Mei: 20:41:50 ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE ON THE ALTERNATIVE. AND AGAIN I THINK IF 20:41:54 ANYONE ANSWER UNCLEAR IF THIS IS THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION THAT WAS MADE 20:41:58 BY COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN AND SECONDED BY VICE MAYOR SHAO. 20:42:04 >> The Clerk: ON THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION. 20:42:08 ROLL CALL VOTE IS COUNCILMEMBER COX. 20:42:11 >> Councilmember Cox: NO. 20:42:15 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN. 20:42:18 >> Councilmember Salwan: NAY. 20:42:22 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN. >> Councilmember Kassan: YES. 20:42:27 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER JONES. >> Councilmember Jones: NAY. 20:42:32 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER KENG. . 20:42:35 >> Councilmember Keng: NAY. 20:42:40 >> Councilmember Salwan: VICE MAYOR SHAO 20:42:43 . >> Councilmember Shao: YEA 20:42:47 . >> The Clerk: MAYOR MEI. >> Mayor Mei: NAY. 20:42:50 SO THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION FAILS WITH TWO AYES AND 20:42:53 FIVE NAYS. 20:42:56 NOW WE'LL GO BACK TO THE MOTION THAT WAS MADE BY COUNCILMEMBER 20:43:00 COX AND SECONDED BY COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN. I BELIEVE 20:43:04 . >> Councilmember Cox: I THINK IT SWITCHED ON THAT ONE 20:43:08 . >> IT WAS SALWAN SECONDED 20:43:11 BY COX. >> Mayor Mei: MOTION 20:43:15 BY COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN AND SECONDED BY COX 20:43:18 . DID WE COULD CLARIFY COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN YOU MOVED 20:43:21 THAT ONE. >> Councilmember Salwan: YES, MOVING STAFF 20:43:24 RECOMMENDATION, DOING IT IN THREE TIERS AS FAR AS THE PRICE INCREASE 20:43:27 ING AND WE ARE CAPPING IT AT $44 FOR 20:43:30 TOWN HOMES AS WELL AS SINGLE FAMILY RESIDENTS 20:43:34 . >> Mayor Mei: SO WITH THAT MAY I HAVE A ROLL CALL VOTE PLEASE. 20:43:37 >> The Clerk: YES MADAM MAYOR. COUNCILMEMBER COX. >> Councilmember Cox: AYE 20:43:39 . >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER SALWAN. 20:43:42 >> Councilmember Salwan: AYE. >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER KASSAN. 20:43:45 >> Councilmember Kassan: NO. 20:43:48 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER JONES. >> Councilmember Jones: AYE. 20:43:51 >> The Clerk: COUNCILMEMBER KENG. >> Councilmember Keng: AYE 20:43:55 . >> The Clerk: VICE MAYOR SHAO. 20:43:58 >> Councilmember Shao: NAY. >> The Clerk: MAYOR MEI. 20:44:01 >> Mayor Mei: AYE. SO THE MATTER PASSES 20:44:05 WITH AFFORDABLE HOUSING MR. PRESIDENT WHICH WILL BE AT THE MAXIMUM 20:44:08 WHICH WAS THE ONLY CONTENTIOUS ITEM, $ 20:44:11 44 FOR BOTH SINGLE FAMILY AND TOWN HOMES AND GOING THROUGH 20:44:14 A THIRD STEP DEAF A 20:44:17 INSTEAD OF A TWO 20:44:20 TWO-STEP. WITH THAT, THAT IS 20:44:23 I THINK THIS IS A OUR LAST AGENDA 20:44:27 ITEM THIS EVENING. AND SEEING NO OTHER THINGS, I WAS IS 20:44:30 GOING TO JUST LET PEOPLE KNOW THAT I APPRECIATE ALL THOSE WHO 20:44:33 CAME OUT TO OUR DOWNTOWN EVENT CENTER. AND 20:44:36 WE APPRECIATE ALL THOSE WHO ARE WORKING WITH US TO KEEP THINGS 20:44:39 GOING IN THE COMMUNITIES. 20:44:43 STAYING HEALTHY. WE ARE NOW AT 97.5% 20:44:46 SINGLE SHOT VACCINATED. 84 20:44:49 .4% FULLY VACCINATED. WE ARE 20:44:52 ACTUALLY TIED WITH OTHER CITIES FOR FIRST PLACE I THINK 20:44:55 IN THE COUNTY FOR SINGLE SHOT WITH PIEDMONT AND 20:44:58 I THINK 20:45:02 THE ALBANY OFF THE TOP OF MY HEAD AND WE ARE 20:45:05 LOOKING TO 20:45:15 THE THIRD DOSE AS NECESSARY. 20:45:18 STAY HEALTH, BE CONSCIENTIOUS, I DMEND 20:45:22 THE STAFF FOR YOUR EFFORTS AT BEING GREEN 20:45:25 AND DISEANABILITY. AND AGAIN, ASK PEOPLE 20:45:28 TO THINK ABOUT CREATING AWARENESS, WHO FILE THERE IS 20:45:31 A NEED FOR DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND AWARENESS, THIS IS THE 20:45:34 MONTH TO DO THAT AND ALSO FOR ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, 20:45:36 MENTAL HEALTH FOR US. THANK YOU SO MUCH AND I'LL 20:45:40 ADJOURN THE MEETING THIS EVENING